Let me first start by saying I hate what Lane Kiffin did to Tennessee football and our fan base...
That being said I believe we lack logic in our assesments of Lane Kiffin's coaching/recruiting ability. Instead everything I read is driven by emotion.
In regards to this thread you can not measure his recruiting ability based on the class retention that he brought into Tennessee. He was not here to mentor, coach, or develop these athletes. Recruiting is only half the battle when it comes to young athletes success and he was not around long enough to prove what he could or could not do with the athletes that matched his style of coaching. The true test will be at USC assuming he has a longer tenure there.
Bottom line he left Tennessee for his dream job, we need to get over ourselves and allow his body of work, or lack there of speak for his coaching abilities. Our fan base continually bringing him up and bashing him does nothing but make us look like the ex-girlfriend that got dumped and now will say anything to make the ex-boyfriend look bad because it in turn makes them look better or feel better. he left, he had his reasons, move on.