First, Rivals is inferior to 247 with respect to talent evals. Rivals has been inferior in that dept for a few years, more noticeable in recent years.
Second, your 5 star list is mostly phony, as is much info you bring here. Shorter was an overrated 5 star recruit out of HS who did nothing at Penn State in two years but get fat literally. He had 147 yards receiving and zero TDs in two years. You can look at 247 to get his rating as a transfer- he’s a 3 star.
Same with Lingard and Cox- overrated HS recruits who didn’t pan out at their original colleges, thus their transfer ratings aren’t 5 stars.
Wingo and Grimes weren’t consensus 5 star recruits. Wingo wasn’t close to a consensus 5 star. I suppose you are relying on the inferior Rivals recruiting info, the site that last year gave a 3 star rating to a recruit that didn’t exist, and frequently rates guys without viewing HS film or watching guys in person.
So, basically you’re trying to make a case using outdated and inferior info. As you told me once even after I corrected more misinformation in one of your earlier posts, TRY TO KEEP UP.