Excellent insights and it is good to be able to finally recognize more of my fellow gray beard cohort of Tennessee fans. Personally, I will withhold judgment for one year to determine precisely which period in Tennessee history is most comparable to what we are currently facing. Why? In order to allow the smoke to clear from an historically bad defensive performance and better assess just where we are in terms of overall talent on that side of the line of scrimmage. We all know that last year we had serious deficiencies in terms of team speed at key positions; they also were adjusting to a defensive scheme for which they were not recruited, one that was exacerbated by inept coaching. The proverbial $64,000 question is how much of a bounceback can we realistically expect with better coaching and a return to the familiar 4-3 scheme. If we post numbers similar to those that we amassed during Wilcoxs season, then that would suggest that the situation, in terms of talent, is not as dire on the defensive side of the ball as last years stats would suggest. The answer to this question, at this point, is, of course, anybodys guess.
In comparing the situation to the beginning of Dickeys tenure, I would like to throw out a few stats that will give our younger readers a greater appreciation for just how radicaland quicklyDickey revamped the offense. As previously noted, we were the last team in the country to give up the General's beloved single-wing and had lost two local quarterback prospects, Steve Spurrier and Steve Sloan, because they could see no place for themselves in our then-antiquated offense. Two years after the installation of Dickey's offense, Dewey Warren became the nation's most efficient passer in 1966.
To demonstrate just how thoroughly Dickey revamped Tennessee's offense, consider the following facts: From 1950 to 1965, no Tennessee player threw more than 79 passes, completed more than 44 attempts, passed for more than 588 yds. or hurled more than 8 touchdown passes. Then, in '66, Dewey Warren attempted 229 passes, of which 136 were complete for 1716 yds. and 18 touchdowns.
During the same period, no Tennessee receiver had caught more than 23 passes or amassed more than 357 yds. receiving in a single season. Then, in 1966, Johnny Mills had 48 receptions for 725 yds. and 4 tds., including a monumental 225-yd. performance against Kentucky, which remains the 3rd most yards in a single game by a Tennessee receiver.
By analogy, you might call that transition comparable to going from a Model T Ford to a Corvette . . . in two years. Personally, I hope that the initial years of Butchs tenure bear more resemblance to Dickeys career path than that of Johnny Majors. Bill Battle was one of the finest PEOPLE we have ever had to occupy the position of head coach at UT, and, yes, he amassed three 10+ win seasons during his first three years on the job, largely with players recruited by Doug Dickey and largely because of great defenses. The talent pool, however, went downhill rapidly because he was not a competent recruiter.
When Johnny came marching home again in 1977, he issued the famous the cupboard is bare comment in describing the quality of personnel that he inherited. Because of those three initial years, Battle actually had a significantly higher winning percentage than Johnny amassed at UT, but it took eight years before Majors returned Tennessee to national prominence with the 1985 season, one that culminated with, perhaps, the single most inspired performance that I have ever seen from a Tennessee football team, a 35-7 annihilation of 2nd-ranked Miami. It took even longer before Tennessee was consistently a force to be reckoned with on the national landscape. That came with back-to-back SEC titles in 1989-90. In short, Battle oversaw the most precipitous decline in Tennessee football fortunes in the last 40 years, with the exception of the last five years. Johnny stated that, in all fairness, the situation that Dooley inherited was probably even worse than what Battle left for him to clean up.