while i never really dispariage anyone for their JG criticisms....couple things people need to keep in mind
1. he's a great practice player. well documented. coaches did not see the game performance coming based on what they saw in practice last year. which is why how the rest of the QB's practice will be important. if any of the three beat JG in practice, that's actually a really good thing....it's the primary reason why i think this QB compeition will be legit.
2. jg's football iq is one thing that did get better in 19 over 18. he didn't take near the amount of bad sacks that he did the year before. and while he still holds the ball too long and is continually late with the delivery, the # of sacks attributed to holding it too long were down...and part of that is because he got a lot better pre snap...note, i didn't say perfect. i said better.
3. progressions and checks are two things that kept JG as the starter and 1st option off the bench. the narrative that he doesn't do checks and doesn't do progressions is wrong....he actually does those very well. Pruitt talked about this a lot during the season....he knows how to get in and out of good/bad plays....
4. the single biggest thing that hurts JG is his ability to see the field after the snap, and throw the ball to the right spot for the WR accurately. he's late with delivery, and throws to the WR, not to where he's going to be.....call it "throw them open", anticipitory, throw with timing....however you want to define it/word it.....that's his main issue, and if not fixed, he likely won't be the starter next year....especially if any of the other three show the aptitude to do that, as well as all the mental stuff that goes with the position.
5. it's totally fair to expect him to have a jump in performance given the situation for is SR season. i think you can't help but get better when you get consistent coaching over extended periods of time. how much better? TBD.
6. i expect HB and BM will push him all off season; and vice versa (assuming BM is still here).