Here are various postings made about Geer: She made a half-hearted effort to catch a ball, she's looked shaky at every at-bat, she was lucky to hit a home run, she doesn't have a true position, she hasn't lived up to expectations, she was a no-show, the pressure got to her, if she can't take it go somewhere else.
But I'm wrong and lost with a weak argument??? All I said was it was one at-bat and to let it go.
All that trash above was said by the rest of you.
Trash? Let's examine what's been said;
1. Half-hearted effort to catch a ball: I said that. From what I saw, if Geer had located the ball a bit early and had tracked the ball one step/one second earlier, it looked as if she might have had a chance to catch the ball. After all, the ball just barely cleared the wall. I was also comparing Geer's fielding prowess in the center field to that of Gaffin's. Who would you rather have in that situation? Trash post? Obviously not. Don't think so. It's a valid argument.
2. She looked shaky at every at-bat: I didn't say that. But she didn't look all that confident against LSU pitchers. I for one 'tho didn't have problems with Geer until that particular at-bat. Trash? Not really. Once again, it's a valid argument IMO.
3. She was lucky to hit a home run against South Carolina: Again, I didn't say that. And I 110% disagree with the statement. She wasn't lucky, she was good to hit that home run. Whosever (shortstop??) said that should apologize to Geer. I think this can be categorized as such (trash).
4. She doesn't have a true position: I didn't quite say that way, but I implied that Geer didn't seem natural at any position she played at. Somebody else said it, but I don't totally disagree. Once again, it's a valid argument from what we've seen of Geer in her three years at UT. Personally, I think she's good enough to play at any position. She's a solid fielder not a great one. Trash? I don't think so. Once again, it's a valid argument IMO.
5. She hasn't lived up to expectations: I didn't say it, and I personally think it's a debatable point. She's lived up to expectations this year for sure. But her first two years, she might have slightly underachieved. Coming out of high school, Geer was such a highly regarded prospect that I personally thought she'd become an All-American by her sophomore year. Trash? Absolutely not. It's a valid argument.
6. She was a no-show: I didn't say it. If referring to SC game, that's obviously wrong. If referring to LSU game, it has some merits depending how one looks at it. Trash? No, I don't think so. It's a valid argument once again.
7. The pressure got to her: I said, "the pressure of the moment might have had the best of her" something along that line in regard to her last at-bat in the bottom of the 7th inning. It's NOT trash at all. It's a very valid point.
8. Go somewhere else, if can't handle the pressure: I think Sandvol said it. He didn't mean for Geer to leave UT for sure. He meant for Geer to be mentally strong and be able to handle the pressurized situation next time. Trash? Absolutely not. Tough love/parental advice? Yes, that's what it seemed to be like from my point.
I for one had no problem with Geer in LSU game except for that one seemingly poor at-bat. We all like Geer and respect her game immensely. But we also want her to be better than what she is, hope she does some great things for UT b/c she's capable of doing such thins. Simply put, we expect a lot out of her. She's one great player/kid. If she can't handle such expectations & gratitude at UT from the fans, I will also suggest her to go some place else to play.