Ginsburg in hospital with "infection"

#10
#10
Amy Barrett is currently in the on deck circle

I've said it before and I'll say it again - I think we should replace like for like.

That said, it would be fun to watch the reaction on the left if Ginsberg needed to be replaced and he nominated M Garland.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Wireless1
#12
#12
What does this mean?

If a liberal comes of the court replace them with a liberal. If a conservative comes off the court replace them with a conservative (something Obama did not do with Scallia). If a swing justice comes of the court replace them with a swing. Keep balance.

IOW, I would not support Brennan for Ginsberg
 
#13
#13
If a liberal comes of the court replace them with a liberal. If a conservative comes off the court replace them with a conservative (something Obama did not do with Scallia). If a swing justice comes of the court replace them with a swing. Keep balance.

IOW, I would not support Brennan for Ginsberg

This is very subjective and would never work in practice.
 
#14
#14
If a liberal comes of the court replace them with a liberal. If a conservative comes off the court replace them with a conservative (something Obama did not do with Scallia). If a swing justice comes of the court replace them with a swing. Keep balance.

IOW, I would not support Brennan for Ginsberg
How about we replace a partisan with a Constitutionalist ? I never understood how 9 judges could look at the same document and then vote differently way too often for comfort...there should be far more 9-0 decisions than 5-4 imo
 
#16
#16
How about we replace a partisan with a Constitutionalist ? I never understood how 9 judges could look at the same document and then vote differently way too often for comfort...there should be far more 9-0 decisions than 5-4 imo

Agreed.
 
  • Like
Reactions: VolnJC
#20
#20
If a liberal comes of the court replace them with a liberal. If a conservative comes off the court replace them with a conservative (something Obama did not do with Scallia). If a swing justice comes of the court replace them with a swing. Keep balance.

IOW, I would not support Brennan for Ginsberg
I guess we are forever past the point where Constitutional experts who arent partisan are sitting at SCOTUS?
 

VN Store



Back
Top