Taking away a first-round draft choice is actually a pretty big punishment, IMO. With that pick, a team that drafts well (like the Patriots) can reasonably expect to get an 7-8 year starter. So for the next eight years or so, that's a hole in the Patriots lineup that will have to be filled somehow. A good starter who probably would have spent the best part of his career with the Patriots is just gone now. I agree that the Patriots got off pretty light, considering how blatantly they appear to have disregarded the commissioner's memo, but taking a good player's whole career away from them isn't exactly insignificant.
Taking away a first-round draft choice is actually a pretty big punishment, IMO. With that pick, a team that drafts well (like the Patriots) can reasonably expect to get an 7-8 year starter. So for the next eight years or so, that's a hole in the Patriots lineup that will have to be filled somehow. A good starter who probably would have spent the best part of his career with the Patriots is just gone now. I agree that the Patriots got off pretty light, considering how blatantly they appear to have disregarded the commissioner's memo, but taking a good player's whole career away from them isn't exactly insignificant.
IMO, taking their first round draft pick was nothing to them. They had 2 and the Pats are so loaded, it really has no immediate impact. Hell, they even traded down with the first round pick they had. They got a mild slap on the wrist because of the SB's they have won over the last few years and they have been portrayed as America's darlings. Bellicheat cheated and knew he was cheating all along. Now that Walsh brought that out, suspend him. Any other form of punishment is laughable.