I hope Chris Johnson tears both of his ACLs

#101
#101
TrueOrange said:
either way, since you have to take all he's already done when making career comparisons, to say anything along the lines of "Britt's better than Wayne at the current moment," is still stretching it
Click to expand...

Which is more realistic?

Garcon > Britt ----or---- Britt > Wayne

By the way, I don't think Britt is better than Wayne but it is the more favorable comparison of the two.
 
#102
#102
TrueOrange said:
either way, since you have to take all he's already done when making career comparisons, to say anything along the lines of "Britt's better than Wayne at the current moment," is still stretching it
Click to expand...

I wouldn't go that far (Britt over Wayne), but it's not as far-fetched as people make it out to be, especially if you actually watch them play on the field.

As posted earlier, former scout Matt Williamson said that Britt was the player that jumped off the film in the Titans-Colts game--a game that Wayne and Garcon obviously played in
 
#103
#103
trevols81 said:
Which is more realistic?

Garcon > Britt ----or---- Britt > Wayne

By the way, I don't think Britt is better than Wayne but it is the more favorable comparison of the two.
Click to expand...

and it has to be one extreme or the other why? Ive been saying that britt being better than Garcon makes sense


but saying Britt better than wayne's too much at the moment
 
#105
#105
You're right, I was dabbling in hyperbole with the Britt/Wayne comment. I'm not saying Britt deserves to be mentioned as a peer of Wayne. However, Britt is more explosive with the ball in his hands than Wayne and is a much more dangerous threat at this point in his career.

Britt's warts are that he's a threat to miss time due to injury or suspension. He's a mental dumpster fire. You don't have those concerns with Wayne, and Wayne has established himself.

Britt has elite talent, though, and that's pretty clear. If he stays healthy and on the field, he's a perennial Pro Bowler. Big "if", though.
 
#106
#106
VKAman said:
Wayne is overrated, but he's good. Collie is very good. Garcon sucks, which is what I said from the beginning.

Seriously, if I were you I would stop before you lose so much credibility that you enter utgibbs territory permanently, but if you really want to keep digging yourself a hole and hoping you'll come out in China feel free to let me know where anything in any of these posts is wrong:

http://www.volnation.com/forum/nfl-...e-chris-johnson-tears-both-3.html#post5453034

http://www.volnation.com/forum/nfl-...e-chris-johnson-tears-both-3.html#post5453054

http://www.volnation.com/forum/nfl-...e-chris-johnson-tears-both-3.html#post5453084

Since I've noticed you stop responding when someone makes you look silly.
Click to expand...

You post someone's opinion. I don't care what some guy from ESPN thinks. Britt has done nothing. Does he have the potential to be better than Garcon yes, but as of today I take Garcon over him. Garcon has over achieved and Britt has under achieved. Make no mistake, Garcon is this team's 4th option. Let me know when Britt does something.
 
#107
#107
TrueOrange said:
and it has to be one extreme or the other why? Ive been saying that britt being better than Garcon makes sense


but saying Britt better than wayne's too much at the moment
Click to expand...

It does not have to be one extreme or the other. I was just pointing out the two comparisons that were addressed in this thread. I clearly stated that I don't agree Britt is better than Wayne.
 
#109
#109
volfanjustin said:
You post someone's opinion. I don't care what some guy from ESPN thinks. Britt has done nothing. Does he have the potential to be better than Garcon yes, but as of today I take Garcon over him. Garcon has over achieved and Britt has under achieved. Make no mistake, Garcon is this team's 4th option. Let me know when Britt does something.
Click to expand...

Nice copout. So what was wrong? Is Britt not fast? Does he not have good hands? Is he not strong? I'm asking you specifically where the opinion is wrong, but you have no idea because you know absolutely nothing about him aside from stats.

And then there are the other two as well. Does Kerry Collins not lead the one dimension of your one-dimensional offense? Does Garcon not drop more passes than all but three guys in the entire league? Those are called facts, my man.

Britt has had 225 yards and 3 TDs in one game. What's Garcon's best game?
 
#111
#111
volfanjustin said:
You all are a joke, and I am the homer here? Britt will never come any where close to Wayne's numbers.
Click to expand...

Considering Britt is 10 years younger, I would probably take him as well. Especially if ole Peyton was my quarterback.
 
#112
#112
volfanjustin said:
You post someone's opinion. I don't care what some guy from ESPN thinks. Britt has done nothing. Does he have the potential to be better than Garcon yes, but as of today I take Garcon over him. Garcon has over achieved and Britt has under achieved. Make no mistake, Garcon is this team's 4th option. Let me know when Britt does something.
Click to expand...

Britt has not underachieved. He's been in the league for two years.
 
#113
#113
VKAman said:
Nice copout. So what was wrong? Is Britt not fast? Does he not have good hands? Is he not strong? I'm asking you specifically where the opinion is wrong, but you have no idea because you know absolutely nothing about him aside from stats.

And then there are the other two as well. Does Kerry Collins not lead the one dimension of your one-dimensional offense? Does Garcon not drop more passes than all but three guys in the entire league? Those are called facts, my man.

Britt has had 225 yards and 3 TDs in one game. What's Garcon's best game?
Click to expand...

He is big and strong, Garcon is way faster. So he has one good game and now he should go to Canton?
 
#114
#114
#116
#116
volfanjustin said:
You all are a joke, and I am the homer here? Britt will never come any where close to Wayne's numbers.
Click to expand...

It helps to have a Hall of Fame quarterback throwing the ball to you for your entire career. If Peyton is out for signifigant time this season I guarantee Wayne's numbers this season will be a fraction of his numbers from '10.
 
#118
#118
#120
#120
Dude, we need to just let this thread die

I don't feel great at all about the top thread in this section of the board being one wishing career ending injury upon a play, regardless of where the discussion might have shifted since

we don't need to do that OP any favors by drawing attention, views, and replies to what was a stupid as well as horrible thread to begin with
 
#121
#121
volfanjustin said:
He is big and strong, Garcon is way faster. So he has one good game and now he should go to Canton?
Click to expand...

Size - Britt
Strength - Britt
Routes - Britt
Hands - Britt
Consistency - Britt
Speed - Garcon, along with Darrius Heyward-Bey and Yamon Figurs

Pierre is better how exactly?

I also want to make it very clear that while VFJ keeps asking what Britt has done, Pierre Garcon has accomplished exactly jack s***.
 
#123
#123
Dude, we need to just let this thread die

I don't feel great at all about the top thread in this section of the board being one wishing career ending injury upon a play, regardless of where the discussion might have shifted since

we don't need to do that OP any favors by drawing attention, views, and replies to what was a stupid as well as horrible thread to begin with
 
New posts
You must log in or register to reply here.

VN Store



Back
Top