All right, all right, all right. I just think you might underestimate how much it sucked to live in the state of Georgia for the several weeks after that game.
But if you really want to make this happen, based on what I've read about rivalry trophies, here's how you go about it. First you get the Georgia Bulldog Glee Club (or Spirit Club, or Pep Club, or whatever) to make a big giant hobnailed boot and parade it around before the UT game for a few years. Then you get our own Glee Club to kidnap it right before the game one year. It vanishes for a few years before the Georgia Glee Club steals it back, and then our guys steal it back, with ever-elevating practical jokes and hijinks surrounding the whole thing. Finally, the university presidents step in to put a stop to it before somebody gets hurt, and we end up with a bunch of rules about where it sits on the sideline during games, whether there might be something like a ceremonial ass-kicking of the losing team's captains afterwards, etc. THEN you've got your tradition-laden obscure rivalry trophy!