dyllisvol42
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- Jan 30, 2013
- Messages
- 2,329
- Likes
- 2,106
I used to go through there on business back in the 80s. Any kid coming out of that area has got to be tough.Kid looks tough as hell and mean. Not to mention he is from east St. Louis. To quote a friend of mine from the area east St. Louis don’t raise no soft a// Bit3)3$
Who cares about a top 10 class. Just get me guys that want to work and have the potential. Let the coaches maximize his potential. If you watch camp drills youll notice very quick feet and great leverage for a guy his size. Had I not know his star ranking before I saw it, Id have thought he was a 4.5 star. He has what it takes.247sports says he is #948 nationally. I don't think that will get you in the top ten class.
But I doubt a program in CFB would have turned him awayAs much as I like him, Kahlil McKenzie was a very high rated lineman, and he played like a 3 star a lot. Same for Drew Richmond. I'm happy for Pruitt to take a 3 star that plays like a 4 or 5 star. The recruiting services do the best they can, but they aren't paid millions to bet on their evaluations.
As much as I like him, Kahlil McKenzie was a very high rated lineman, and he played like a 3 star a lot. Same for Drew Richmond. I'm happy for Pruitt to take a 3 star that plays like a 4 or 5 star. The recruiting services do the best they can, but they aren't paid millions to bet on their evaluations.
247sports says he is #948 nationally. I don't think that will get you in the top ten class.
As much as I like him, Kahlil McKenzie was a very high rated lineman, and he played like a 3 star a lot. Same for Drew Richmond. I'm happy for Pruitt to take a 3 star that plays like a 4 or 5 star. The recruiting services do the best they can, but they aren't paid millions to bet on their evaluations.
As much as I like him, Kahlil McKenzie was a very high rated lineman, and he played like a 3 star a lot. Same for Drew Richmond. I'm happy for Pruitt to take a 3 star that plays like a 4 or 5 star. The recruiting services do the best they can, but they aren't paid millions to bet on their evaluations.
Kahlil had the disadvantage of not being allowed to play his senior year of HS. Gained a bunch of weight and never recovered. Had Fitzgerald been here, there would have been a greater chance they both might have reached their potential. Plus it turns out, Kahlil should have played O-Line.
The recruiting services exist because of the nationwide interest in college football. Because of people like us. They make their best guess on these players. Coaching evaluation are more in depth (hopefully), and (hopefully) they include work ethics. If Pruitt and Friend feel he has the right work ethic, I would take 3 stars like him all day long.
I think my main point was that they have a lot more at stake on their evals, and successful coaches probably are better judges than guys who do interviews and podcasts for a living (no offense to those guys).Especially lower end guys. Barton even had a really nice reply recently on our board as to why guys like Means and Solomon were lower rated (someone just kindly asked what traits/attributes they were lacking to drag their ranking down). His answer was, in short, some guys won't always put up stats or flash on tape or even camp, but you have to trust a team's or set of teams (based on offers) eval in that case, because they have seen the kid up and close and done tons of research on him. Obviously services can dig deep on thousands of kids, but D1 programs have the resources to dive deeper on dozens or even hundreds.
Of course, all that still always leaves me slightly uneasy. It's easy to say "trust the coaches" and "they are betting their million dollar jobs on these evals", but so are tons of other coaches and programs and they can't all be right. Obviously Dooley and Butch weren't right as often as they needed to be. One can hope, off recommendations (granted, while at Alabama/UGA) that Pruitt is the elite evaluator many say he is. But now he is at UT, not Bama/UGA. Time will tell and we will all sit here in the dark until then.
But we can and should stay optimistic, if only for our own health.