BJSforVols
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- Oct 23, 2008
- Messages
- 4,858
- Likes
- 2,019
It is such a bad situation. If the players want VY, they won't respond to a coach who exiles him; however, what coach shouldn't shun a player that acted as VY has on and off the field (specifically taunting the fans and throwing the equipment)
The QB needs to be a leader, VY is not. The coach needs to have total control of his squad, Fisher does not.
For the record, I stay with Fisher one more year over VY. If Adams and Co. side with a player over a coach, that will be a trend that will only demolish a fading franchise. I do not think Fisher is our answer, but I could care less to see Vy back under center without a complete turnaround of his attitude and leadership.
I agree with you in regards to how Young reacted. He didn't act professional and does not act as a leader. But, if the players are taking his side, it indicates the players agreed with whatever beef Young had with Fisher. If Fisher has lost the players, then there's no reason to stay with him another year. If the players don't respect Fisher, Fisher will never be able to get them under control.
It is such a bad situation. If the players want VY, they won't respond to a coach who exiles him; however, what coach shouldn't shun a player that acted as VY has on and off the field (specifically taunting the fans and throwing the equipment)
The QB needs to be a leader, VY is not. The coach needs to have total control of his squad, Fisher does not.
For the record, I stay with Fisher one more year over VY. If Adams and Co. side with a player over a coach, that will be a trend that will only demolish a fading franchise. I do not think Fisher is our answer, but I could care less to see Vy back under center without a complete turnaround of his attitude and leadership.
I agree with you in regards to how Young reacted. He didn't act professional and does not act as a leader. But, if the players are taking his side, it indicates the players agreed with whatever beef Young had with Fisher. If Fisher has lost the players, then there's no reason to stay with him another year. If the players don't respect Fisher, Fisher will never be able to get them under control.
NASHVILLE, Tenn. -- The buzz here in the wake of a 17-6 loss to the Jacksonville Jaguars is that the Tennessee Titans have quit on Jeff Fisher.
I think people who think that dont really understand what quitting means and mistake ineffectiveness for lack of effort. They must not have seen Dallas under Wade Phillips or Minnesota under Brad Childress, which is quite a bit different than Fisher's Titans against Jacksonville.
A good share of the Titans still played hard in the second half of Sundays rout. The Titans didnt give up a point.
This team didnt quit, they didnt give up a point in the second half, Fisher said at his Monday press conference. They got a third-down stop, they blocked a field goal and they played hard. We just didnt make the plays.
Michael Griffin doesnt get embarrassingly stiff-armed by Maurice Jones-Drew right near the end of the game if hes not chasing in the first place. Not chasing is quitting. Getting pushed aside by an excellent player who's having a great day is different.
There may be a handful of guys who realize their fate with the team is sealed and arent going all out.
But a team quitting is a pretty rare thing in the league. If players put that on film, they know this coach or the other 31 in the league will ultimately see it. The Titans roster may be loaded with guys who arent that good, but I think they understand the concept of their weekly resumes.
So I believe Chris Hope, who missed too many tackles. I believe Stephen Tulloch, who was credited with 17.
No sir, by no means do I believe Fisher has lost this team or that guys have quit, Hope said. We had plenty of opportunities to quit this game and we made it a game, we had a chance to actually come back. A few balls bounce the right way on the offensive side of the ball and its a ball game. That just lets you know right then and there that we havent quit.
Weve got a great group of guys here that would give anything they have for one other, Tulloch said. Were not quitting. Were going to keep fighting to find a way to win.
And why would a Bo Scaife or a Nate Washington bail on Fisher when, in assessing their drops on Monday, the coach tried to explain them away by saying it wasnt an easy day to catch the football with the weather the way it was?
The game book says it was 35 degrees with a 26-degree wind chill and winds of 11 miles an hour at LP Field.
It's a good thing Scaife and Washington werent playing in Cincinnati, Green Bay, Kansas City, New York or Baltimore -- NFL venues that had lower temperatures and wind chills and higher winds than Nashville on Sunday.
Vince Young (Houston,TX)
Is the swing from 5-2 to 5-7 and from the offense with the highest PPG in the NFL to one of the lowest evidence that I am a more important piece of the offense in Tennessee than people give me credit for?
Paul Kuharsky (3:05 PM)
Nope. Your inability to lead has helped produce these results even if you haven't been playing. You helped create the situation and atmosphere. It's about more than Sundays, Chief.
He probably has zero value right now. There isn't many contending teams with a demand for a quarterback.
And when the players run the show, which would be the main thing some would take from Vince Young forcing Jeff Fisher out, no coach could easily step in and gain their trust and assert any authority. The Titans are already undisciplined enough. They might both need to go.
watch for when this changes from last weekend:
Too easy to say Titans have quit - AFC South Blog - ESPN
It was seen in the Dallas situation earlier this year, when any interviews where whenever a question about Wade was brought up, no matter who it was the player said "I'm not going to say anything about that." That's when you've lost the team.
That said, isn't Britt also good friends with Young anyways? (not just team comradory). Again you need to see more than just this one incident and see more players repeatedly dodging questions before one starts declaring that whole "lost" thing.
hm, I think the analyst noted this one well actually:
Chat: Chat with Paul Kuharsky - SportsNation - ESPN
I'm a Jeff Fisher fan. Should he be fired? I'm not sure. I've always stuck with Fisher and I certainly respect those opinions that disagree with me on that. I've never been a Vince Young fan. I'll go on the record to say that I wanted the Titans to draft Leinart. That would have been a bust, obviously. Vince was having his most accurate year as a passer this year. He was really impressing me. That said, how can the team choose Young? The same Young that cried when fans booed him off the field and thought about suicide a few years ago? The same Young who was supposed to have "changed" after the strip club incident? The same Young who walked out on his teammates earlier this year? In the end, I think Fisher will be fired and Adams will choose Young and I can't defend Fisher. As a coach, he's been inmature over the entire ordeal, but how can you put faith in a quarterback that shows he's mentally weak and has quit on his coaches, teams, and fans numerous times?