I was for a rematch initially but now I think OkSt should get the nod. While I do think Bama is the better team they only beat 3 teams with an above .500 record (Penn St, Ark &, Auburn). OkSt beat 7 (including OU, Texas, Baylor and Kansas St.).
Now I know the argument is "but its the SEC" and normally I would agree. Bama's East opponents were 5-7 TN, 6-6 Vandy, and 6-6 FL. Some say UGA backed into the SECCG because they played a weak SEC schedule. Well, outside of LSU (loss) and Ark so did Bama.
Again, I think Bama would beat OKSt but its about your season resume and not who looks better on paper. OkSt's resume looks a little better.