Mark Rypien -vs- Steve McNair

[superdave1984]

Google Angela Rypien before you vote.

 

[WA_Vol]

my vote for McNair

He's 6th all time in rushing yards and had a better passing rating:

McNair
82.8 passer rating

Rypien
78.9 passer rating

 

[ENGRVOL]

Rypien benefited from having Joe Gibbs as his head coach. Gibbs won super bowls with three different quarterbacks. I don't know of too many coaches that have done that.

 

[MemphianVol]

McNair was one of the toughest SOBs I ever saw play. I love my Skins, but I'm riding with SM.

 

[2ironVol]

Mark Rypien
awards
3× Pro Bowl selection (1989, 1991, 1993)
Super Bowl MVP (XXVI)
2× Super Bowl champion (XXII, XXVI)

Steve McNair
awards
3× Pro Bowl selection (2000, 2003, 2005)
AP NFL MVP (2003)

who was the better QB?

What years were either of them All-Pro. All-Pro is much more exclusive and prestigious than making a pro bowl