Meyer or Saban?

[Lawrence Wright]

Tom Osbourne

Active coaches....

 

[MyBloodRunnethOrange]

Simply put, Nick Saban better collapse soon. I can't stand the thought of him overtaking The Bear in any way.

Why would you care?

 

[roddo518]

Saban trumps Spurrier, Fulmer and Vince Dooley by virtue of winning more national titles than those three combined.

But roddo's post about Saban being the best of all-time at sustaining an elite program might be one his less intelligent posts, which is saying something.

Saban has went 84-11 over the last seven years and that's after he put LSU on the map. He's won 3ncs in that span. Id say he can sustain an elite program. Bear won 137-38-5 with six titles at Bama. If you project Sabans record and NCs it goes to 168-22 and six NCs, add his first year and his record 175-28. I'd like you to name a coach that's done better in the modern era? This should be good. I'm awaiting one of your many unintelligent responses.

 

[MyBloodRunnethOrange]

Saban has went 84-11 over the last seven years and that's after he put LSU on the map. He's won 3ncs in that span. Id say he can sustain an elite program. Bear won 137-38-5 with six titles at Bama. If you project Sabans record and NCs it goes to 168-22 and six NCs, add his first year and his record 175-28. I'd like you to name a coach that's done better in the modern era? This should be good. I'm awaiting one of your many unintelligent responses.

Braynt's record at Alabama was 232-46-9.

 

[Lawrence Wright]

Braynt's record at Alabama was 232-46-9.

It's like roddo makes $h!t up, expecting no one to call him out on it. lol:

Nick Saban is an elite coach, and as far as active coaches go you can easily argue he's the best of the bunch.

But to say he's the best of all-time, without actually surpassing accomplishments of the all-time greats, is complete nonsense.

 

[roddo518]

Braynt's record at Alabama was 232-46-9.

You are correct sir. I was looking at overall record vs sec in his Bama history. I looked at the wrong column. Sabans projected record at Bama is still very comparable if not better. Just trying to prove that my statement was not as far fetched as some would lead you to believe.

 

[Lawrence Wright]

You are correct sir. I was looking at overall record vs sec in his Bama history. I looked at the wrong column. Sabans projected record at Bama is still very comparable if not better. Just trying to prove that my statement was not as far fetched as some would lead you to believe.

In other words, you were dead wrong.

 

[roddo518]

In other words, you were dead wrong.

Hell, I hate the guy. Plus I'm tired of looking at all his successful statistics, but if you project it out for another ten years at Bama he will claim the title.

 

[SmokeyFTW]

Who's your #2 and #3?

#2 Brad Scott

#3 Joker Phillips

 

[Jax_Vol]

#2 Brad Scott

#3 Joker Phillips

I thought it was Ron Zook and Will Muschump

 

[NoogaVFL]

#2 Brad Scott

#3 Joker Phillips

Joker Phillips is the best recruiting propaganda artist/MS Paint expert of all time.

 

[Aesius]

They're 1a and 1b to me.

In terms of sheer coaching ability, my top 10 college coaches of the last decade are:

1. Meyer
2. Saban
3. Harbaugh
4. Carroll
5. Chip Kelly
6. Patterson
7. Petersen
8. Snyder
9. Fisher
10. Malzahn

Pinkel is a strong candidate for top 10 as well.

 

[SmokeyFTW]

They're 1a and 1b to me.

In terms of sheer coaching ability, my top 10 college coaches of the last decade are:

1. Meyer
2. Saban
3. Harbaugh
4. Carroll
5. Chip Kelly
6. Patterson
7. Petersen
8. Snyder
9. Fisher
10. Malzahn

Pinkel is a strong candidate for top 10 as well.

I'm glad you put Snyder in there. Great coach. I might even move him up a bit on the list.