So was 2023 the "norm" and 2022 the "outlier"? Or should I expect more out of this team in 2024?
IMO, 2022 is the outlier and 2023 is
closer to the norm, although I think they could have done better in certain games/moments. UT has a brutal conference schedule year after year, and winning 10/11 games is very difficult and hard to sustain, and shouldn't be expected in this conference unless you can recruit in the top 4 year after year. You should expect better QB play in 2024, which is key to offensive success, and I would also expect improvement in the defensive secondary as many bad players should move on.
I can't agree that these teams are "essentially the same." They are very different in skill, ability, personality, and leadership at many important positions, including coaching staff, which is the norm across college football year to year, even for the "elite" programs. Any coach at any level for any sport will tell you that.
I also can't agree that next year "means everything," buts that's just me, personally. It's just college football, and I have been a fan in both good times and bad. Even for the players and coaches. They have family, friends, and futures that mean more than just one season of football.