Not in Jordan Siebert's

[hatvol96]

I am not buying that he is highly overrated.

Then you're passing on buying the truth.

 

[hatvol96]

He is overrated as hell on Rivals. How do I know? Because Rivals sucks.

We have a winner.

 

[Griffmann]

None of the sites I respect have him rated highly.

What sites do you follow for recruiting info?

 

[hatvol96]

What sites do you follow for recruiting info?

Van Coleman's Hoopmasters is probably the best site in terms of evaluation. The only problem is that they are a little slow in updating their player ratings and school lists. Prepstars is also very good.

 

[TheScottyHopson]

Also I should have put a disclaimer, I am only not buying that he is overrated if he stays a 5-star. I am not confident he will do that but if he does, he is a big-time prospect.

Here is rivals Final ranking stats on bball 5-stars:

2007 - 2/28 were not instant impact players in college

2006 - 4/28 (I couldn't find 2 of them so I am assuming grade problems) were not great but 3 of them were still contributers/starters

2005 - 2/25 (which I couldn't find those 2)

2004 - 1/30

2003 - 3/25... 3 guys I haven't heard of and am too lazy to find their college stats

12/136= 8.8% in 5 years... definitely take yalls word over Jerry Meyer's. It also could be considered lower depending on what a "bust" is and 6 from 2006-07 could get better. I don't really see why everyone is bashing rivals... looks like a pretty good job to me.