So what part of the art of the deal involves trading all the leverage in the world for absolutely nothing?
Lets clear up a few things. The Donalds decision is not about climate change, coal miners, or the American economy. Its not about renegotiating a better deal for America. I see a few of you whining that Italy, Germany, and France dont want to renegotiate. Thats a delay tactic; weve been negotiating for decades. What is there to renegotiate? All of the commitments are voluntary. The only thing the Paris Climate Agreement asks is that each country have an emissions reductions goal, submit its plan detailing how it will reach said emissions reduction goal, and that countries get together to review their progress every five years. The $3 billion commitment to the Green Climate Fund, of which we only paid out $1 billion, is not going to wreck our economy. China, who already spends much more money investing in clean energy than the US, had already committed $3.1 billion (thats right, theyre paying in, not cashing out). China and Europe have already stated they will step up to fill the void left by the US. Considering we managed to negotiate Loss and Damage out of the PCA in exchange for the GCF, that really was already a great deal for the worlds historically largest CO2 emitter.
And remember, the commitments were VOLUNTARY. If Trump wanted to renegotiate the deal, he could have simply resubmitted a far less ambitious plan (like Russia) and not sent any money to the GCF, while maintaining a seat at the table. This was not about an imaginary burden on the US economy. As
this insightful piece puts it
Trumpites think were putting the coal miners back to work. Trump loves "clean, clean, coal", right? Wrong. He proposed cutting 85% of DoEs budget for carbon capture technology, the only thing that could possibly make coal viable in the long term (and thats still decades away if it ever materializes). But ditching climate change efforts will totally bring back coal jobs right?
Top US coal boss Robert Murray: Trump 'can't bring mining jobs back'
Coal has been on a downward spiral for decades and is dying out now due to competition from cheap natural gas and alternatives, not because of Obama, not because of Paris. And even if Trump managed to slow coals death spiral, it wouldnt help the coal miners. For years coals business model has been to extract more coal with fewer people. Mechanization. And if its about jobs,
why are we trying to revive an industry that employs fewer people than Arbys. Heck, solar alone already employs twice as many people as coal. One sector is growing rapidly and the other
not so much.
So what have we accomplished? Weve alienated our allies in the international community. Weve lost whatever respect and influence we still had. We lost our ability to hold other countries accountable under the PCA. We are surrendering our position as a leader in the future energy economy. We are no longer the leaders of the free world. For what? Donald Trump gave up all that political capital for what? Art of the deal LOL
On the bright side, this will finally thrust the climate change issue into the spotlight in the US. Apparently the Donald has indicated that they will do the 4 year withdrawal from the PCA but not the UNFCCC. That means the earliest the US could withdraw is Nov. 4, 2020 the day after the next presidential election.