What is silly about hiring a top coaching candidate with Final Four experience, a love of Tennessee, and recent history of running a clean program?
That you have to ask is concerning enough, but here goes...
Bruce Pearl broke the same rule at Tennessee that he had previously broken at UW-Milwaukee. He then lied about it, and asked the parent of the recruit in question to lie about it, as well. His sudden attack of conscience was only brought on by the revelation that the NCAA already had all the proof they needed to nail him as a repeat offender. After that, he continued his cavalier approach to the NCAA rulebook by impermissably contacting another recruit.
For all of this, he was fired, and he took an enormous dump on his assistant coaches behind closed doors as he negotiated his own $1 million buyout, and did nothing for his assistants who put their careers on the line in an attempt to cover up his mess. The NCAA gave him a 3-yr show-cause penalty.
Auburn hires him, and after some lean years, he makes a breakthrough toward unprecedented success, but amidst that newfound success, he also has to answer questions for the shady character and misdeeds of one of his assistants within the FBI probe, in which, Pearl initially refused to cooperate.
Now, you, the poster and fan, may be able to justify to yourself and explain away his entire career of shady behavior, but if Tennessee's administration were foolish enough to rehire Pearl, and he hasn't learned from his mistakes, well the NCAA isn't going to be so kind to a school administration who was fleeced twice by the same guy who frankly just took a "piss on your rules" approach to the NCAA.
There is just too much coaching talent out there to risk your program's future and livlihood on the back of man who has knowingly screwed Tennessee before and apparently has no concept of the phrase, "If you lie with dogs, you're bound to get fleas." If not willfully reckless, he has certainly shown himself to be grossly negligent and careless with regard to the NCAA rulebook and with the behavior of his assistants.
Simply put, Tennessee cannot afford to stake its reputation on his shady character. They don't need him.