Tennessee basketball fans as a whole have become greedy instead of grateful. No Barnes hasn't gotten us over the hump but he has the program at the best position its ever been. No other coach in its history has had this much sustainable success.
True. Barnes has brought us back to relevance and beyond. And I confess to being “greedy” for championships…more than the SEC tournament. I am greedy for a program that is also greedy, that always hungers for a national championship, that is talented and balanced and well-coached enough to go deeper in the tourney than we have ever been, a team that is never satisfied, and a team where every single player is greedy for the ball when the game is on the line.
I think Coach Barnes may want those things, too. But it seems he may not really know how to build such a team and program. I write that with great respect and simply looking at his body of work over the years, here and elsewhere. Seems his teams are always good enough to get to the tournament but with an expected low ceiling. He seems stubborn and not open to making changes to improve his results…and I mean significant changes at the strategic level, from recruiting to in-game coaching to player development.
Building a strong tournament team begins with recruiting of course. And coaching a strong tournament team begins in August…not at the end of the regular season. Does Coach Barnes have a tournament-winning strategy each August? Who knows?
Finally, I get the sense that Coach Barnes always recruits and coaches players to fit into his system rather than adapting his system to the skills and talents of each player on the team. We have a few four- and five-star recruits on our team, if memory serves. But they have all underachieved, it seems. Why? I think one reason might be that he won’t let them play unless and until they master his defensive regime.
I have heard him use the phrase “defensive liability” when describing some players, e.g. when asked why this it that player was pulled from a game, why this or that player wasn’t getting minutes.
I respect that but, as I see it, high school basketball players do not get rated four and five stars by being defensive standouts or making the fewest turnovers. I believe that, rightly or wrongly, they earn those stars primarily by being scorers.
And then some of them get into Barnes’s system and they learn how to play his brand of defense. If they make a mistake, he sits them down and limits their minutes. So, when they next get into a game, they play tight and afraid of screwing up rather than playing and attacking like greedy, fearless young men who want to light up the world.
This is all pure speculation on my part, of course, the theory being that Barnes’s system is not really built for scorers. It’s “defense first” and whatever happens after that. My opinion is that maybe he’s not letting some players be who they are —scorers first. As a result, they never play loose but uptight and risk-averse because their coach is risk-averse. Scared money can’t win.
Our defense absolutely won us some games this year, like Duke. But our lack of scoring absolutely lost us some games…probably more games than our defense won for us. Everybody sees the obvious…that we need more scorers. But what good would that do if they’re not allowed to make a few mistakes while helping the team put up 80 points most times out?
Barnes needs to turn these guys loose and let them play loose while also playing suffocating defense. It can be done.
Adapt your system to the players you have, Coach Barnes. Let them be who they are. If you do that, I am confident your legacy will improve…as will our team’s wins in the tournament.
Above all else, get greedy.