(VolBeef88 @ May 11 said:
I didn't think you were bashing him. I just think it is more impressive than perhaps you are giving him credit. As an old Linebacker I can tell you. You don't need much film on a teams running game that has a horrible passing game. You stick 8 in the box and hold your lanes. The thing about good backs jake is that they usually have great vision and the ability to hit the opening. So film on him is not as big as you may think. Yes it was only 5 games. But hey, that is 5 games that we saw. You could easily say that he may have had an even better year if he started off the season because teams early were watching our passing game.
again, i don't disagree.....and i never said he wasn't impressive, i was very impressed, and in fact after the USC game, i was wondering to myself, where has this guy been all season?
but it still stands to reason that they guy that started those last 5 games won't more than likely put up those same kind of results in 06 (people talking him up for heismen this, 1600 yards that...), for all the reason i've already stated. And to expect that is setting yourself up to be disappointed, because as of right now, he's the only thing our offense has going for it. He's the only thing you can look back on in 05 with any kind of optimism.
And the the simple fact still remains, he didn't put up those numbers as a starter against LSU, UF, UGA, Bama etc....it was agains Vandy, KY, MEmphis etc...and again, i'm not saying he won't do well against them, just that it will be interesting to see if he will...playing a 12 game schedule as the feature back against all of that competition is a far cry from doing it in 5 games where 3 or 4 of those teams were not real good on D.
Until we prove we can function at other aspects of the offense, the running game will most likely suffer, no matter how good AF is, and i do think he's good...
I just think the expectations for AF should be tempered with the overall performance of the offense, and right now, we just don't know how that's all going to play out. So it's really difficult for me to say that he's GOING to do this or that. Sure he's capable, no doubts or arguements with that, and all the points you've raised about his vision, ability to hit the hole etc...are all valid, and are all reasons why he would flourish, if the rest of our offense comes together with him.
it just can't be a one man show, that's all.