Perry strikes me as the same. Romney really is a Northeast Republican and sitting almost dead in the center (left of the other two, if only slightly)
I really think had Gore become the president we would have been a lot worse off. His environmental desires alone would have crippled this economy. And he would have not aggressively taken the fight to the terrorists back yard either. I know the wars are not popular, but given the time and circumstances I am sorry I can't blame him for that decision at all. I believe with all my heart Iraq had WMD's. When you have 4 or 5 years of warning, with it really ramping up in the final 12 months or so. It doesn't take that long to move them out of an area the size of one of our states to a neighboring country.
I think Kerry would have ended up looking identical to Obama is now. He would not have been able to ram Kerrycare through as easily, but policy wise they would have been identical. The only if is, I really think he would have pulled the trigger on pulling out of the Middle East. And love it or hate it, that would have been a disaster at that time.
The Republican's biggest mistake in that time was they did dick all on the domestic front in a way to try to buy love from the Democrats and it back fired. I really wish they would take note on how the Democrats banded together in the period from 2007-2011 and how much they got done and actually grow some balls and do the same to try to undo some of this mess that has been hoisted on us.