[Removing blind Gator-hate] [Donning unbiased jacket]
In all honesty, I think Tebow was the perfect fit for the offense Urban ran at the UF. He was mobile. He was bullish, as our own Eric Berry said, he was a load.
On the pro level he was adequate in Denver. He crashed and burned with the NYJ not because he is a bad QB. But because the Jets coach doesn't know what the heck he wants offense-wise. Consequentially, either does Sanchez ( who is overrated) nor Tebow. Had he gone to a team with a coach who actually knows how to use and develop him, he'd perform better. Add to this the fact that it appears most of the Jets players didn't want him and if you think that doesn't reflect in the locker room, you're nuts. This will wear on any player no matter who you are.
He did better in Denver than NY. Elway parted ways ONLY because he was able to acquire P. Manning. Prior to that, Elway was singing how Tebow was his QB. In Denver, Tebow had player and management support, and time on the field to do what he does by instinct. To wit, create plays on the fly. But he never had real development there and that's not his fault.
However, what is his fault is that while at Florida, he rejected the opportunity to receive development. He literally told the QB coach to work with the other quarterbacks instead. This did and has cost him as a pro player. Remember he had to work on his mechanics when he first went to the combine and then again as a pro. His throwing motion was horrible. He cheated himself in this aspect. Like Tyler Bray, he relied on his natural raw talent and never did develop.
NO! I'm not a Tebow fan but I respect him as a person. He knew how to keep his pants zipped. He knew how to stay out of trouble. He actually tried to steer his more trouble-prone UF teammates to being trouble-free. Didn't work but the fact he tried says a lot about the player as a MAN. If and when my fellow Vols fans can lift the veil of jealous hate, for that's all it is, and see with unbiased eyes, you may figure out what I know some day. He was an arena style player who whipped our butts each time we went up against him. I didn't like it either but it is what it is.