Stoops gets the nod for 3 reasons. Longevity, making it 11 going on 12 years at Kentucky is an achievement in and of itself. He gets credit for winning the amount of games he has in the location he is in, its impressive what he's done at Kentucky. Family name recognition.
I know it wont be popular but to me winning as much as he has done at UK is a bigger achievement than what CJH has done at UT. In a vacuum. But taking into account what happened the preceding 15+ years at UT the turnaround JCH has accomplished is impressive. More impressive is the culture they have built or better said done away with. If you factor in the social media era players get in a lot less trouble under him, we graduate a lot more guys and retain more guys compared to those who preceded him. I know it seems like we see UT players in the news but trust me If social media was what it is now back in the 80's-2010's... you don't wanna be there and that's true for almost all big programs. Players in the 90's and even early 2000's didn't have to deal with the cloutchasing and misinformed public. Back then groupies, fans etc were just that. now people are out there trying to make it big off your fall. GIven that CJH has done an amazing job and that's not taking into account his results on the field which thus far have been stellar. For CJH his problem is expectations.. both fans and the media expect more from UT than is realistic IMHO.... IF Kentucky makes a bowl that was a big deal before Stoops got there. Kentucky has been to 23 bowl games.. ever. 8 were Stoops 4 Bear Bryant. UT 56. Without digging too deep its pretty safe to say anyone that's coached at UT for more than a year has made a bowl.
My point is doing well at a good program is less of an indicator than doing well data bad one. Historically. If you can win at Vandy you can win anywhere is a fact....I you can win at UT or Bama or UGa well its kinda hard not to win there. My point is CJH being behind Stoops right now is kind of compliment to the program. If he keeps it up another couple years that story changes. Because winning consistently in the SEC is no joke