volinbham
VN GURU
- Joined
- Oct 21, 2004
- Messages
- 69,811
- Likes
- 62,587
Ok thoughts... was that a fumble or no?
Not a fumble imo. He's down, hand on ball but jmo
I think so!
was losing control as he was going down
wow. That's a technicality if I've ever seen one. The Player was down, the player had the ball under his hand'control, and the play was not blown dead.
The ball was coming out.
He didn’t maintain full possession, hence why it was a fumble.
I thought he was grasping it but the review showed his hand was just laying on it. That is not control.
So if his elbow or knee is down no fumble, but whole body it's a fumble ok I get it
I guess a hand on the ball is not enough to consider he had control.
I saw it coming out, but then he's completely down, hand on ball, then they take the ball. Should be dead, but jmo
Ok that settles it. We are as indecisive as the refs.He didn’t control it. Hand was just laying on top of the ball.