OP has some valid points. As with anything, there are grey areas. The health of a program is not strictly based on W-L record. No matter how you slice it, Dooley and his family are real, live human beings, with emotions. They aren't robots. Just because our W-L record isn't what we want, it doesn't mean he is a bad person, a jerk, an a** hole, etc. I think we SHOULD thank him for working his tail off for this program, and at the same time, tell him goodbye. Very few people argue with the idea that Dooley's outcome is unacceptable, but that's no reason to act like he's a piece of crap.
Well if he is a piece of crap, he is a rich one!