The Braves Thread

#223,052
#223,052
zjcvols said:
Of course, but the committee is supposed to rank all 25 and that was as if the next team couldn't play for example. But I really wonder what the committee would have done with 2022 Tennessee/Alabama for example when they ranked Bama ahead of us with the same record if there was a 12 team playoff (Both would have got in anyways but seeding does matter)
Click to expand...
Yeah they're supposed to, but when you allow more teams in the incentives change, so I wonder of that changes how they'd rank them.

For example, in the 4-team playoff, say everything suggests ranking a particular team #4, but that sets up a rematch of a regular season or conference title game that they don't want (at least in the semifinal round). You know they'd rank that team #2 or #3. Under the old BCS, they would rank that team #4, and it didn't matter because only #1 and #2 played for the title.

The historical precedents are interesting, and maybe they'll hold, but they were also making those rankings knowing only the top 4 played for the title.
 
#223,053
#223,053
zjcvols said:
Of course, but the committee is supposed to rank all 25 and that was as if the next team couldn't play for example. But I really wonder what the committee would have done with 2022 Tennessee/Alabama for example when they ranked Bama ahead of us with the same record if there was a 12 team playoff (Both would have got in anyways but seeding does matter)
Click to expand...
I'm not sure. That dynamic in 2022 was kind of the opposite of what we were discussing yesterday, which is that the committee seems to care who you beat more than who you lost to. I'm sure there was some benefit of the doubt there; if 2 teams are really close, give it to the one who has been more dominant over the preceding years.

We beat Alabama and LSU (who they also lost to), but their losses were really good (both one-possession road games that came down to the last play) while our loss to South Carolina was an absolute abomination.
 
#223,065
#223,065
We gotta at least give Georgia a game, if we don’t win, and we need Arky to win out to make that loss look better.

Another possible interesting scenario. If one loss Texas A&M beats one loss Texas, does Texas still get in?
 
#223,066
#223,066
It’s incredible watching those two assholes from last night try and get popular that Steve Bartman literally turned down hundreds of thousands of dollars in opportunities and refused to participate in a documentary because he truly felt bad about what he did
 
  • Like
Reactions: Volfan1000, 05_never_again and LotteryPick
#223,068
#223,068
zjcvols said:
It’s incredible watching those two assholes from last night try and get popular that Steve Bartman literally turned down hundreds of thousands of dollars in opportunities and refused to participate in a documentary because he truly felt bad about what he did
Click to expand...
From the outside, seems like typical yankees.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 05_never_again, LotteryPick, 95 Vol Alum and 1 other person
New posts
You must log in or register to reply here.

VN Store



Back
Top