I think Murphy has found his home in the cleanup spot. He should be playing 3/4 or 4/5 going forward between C/DH. TDA can bat cleanup when Murphy gets a day off. 5-9 some variation of Eddie/TDA/Vaughn, Mike, Oz, but I think:
TDA
Mike
Vaughn/Arcia
Oz
Eddie/Sam
Gives us the most balance and sets the top of the order up to mash pens.