RiotVol
I Am Jack's Complete Lack of Surprise
- Joined
- Dec 25, 2011
- Messages
- 3,485
- Likes
- 12,639
'22 TN QB Ty Simpson (Alabama commit)
- Thread starter Jxn Vol
- Start date
LittleVol
Of course I can help you, Coach Heupel.
- Joined
- Oct 10, 2014
- Messages
- 22,104
- Likes
- 38,939
Peyton Manning 2A
Randall Cobb 2A
Patrick Willis 1A
Derricky Henry 2A
Fred Taylor 2A
Deion Sanders 2A
Percy Harvin 3A
Michael Vick 3A
Ed Reed 3A
Justin Harrell 2A
Reggie White 2A
Chris Leak 6A...
What EXACTLY do you mean when you say "it matters"??
Again, we're talking about an INDIVIDUAL. Not a team.
It's not 1 dude vs 11 out there. It's a team vs another team. So WHEN and HOW does level of competition factor in?
Would Vick had run 4.1 had he played 5A ball???
You keep saying it matters. HOOOOOOOW???
HOOOOOW DOOOOOOES IT MATTEEEER???
montanatenn
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- Mar 15, 2015
- Messages
- 2,505
- Likes
- 3,240
appvol
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- Apr 1, 2009
- Messages
- 2,888
- Likes
- 16,847
BigOrangeTrain
Morior Invictus
- Joined
- Jan 30, 2013
- Messages
- 78,743
- Likes
- 90,617
peaygolf
The "Fly" is open.....Let's Go Peay!!!!
- Joined
- Nov 30, 2017
- Messages
- 25,516
- Likes
- 122,243
appvol
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- Apr 1, 2009
- Messages
- 2,888
- Likes
- 16,847
bigl3327
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- Sep 16, 2009
- Messages
- 6,962
- Likes
- 34,456
SugarCC
Gntlmen, u cant fight here, this is the war room!
- Joined
- Jul 29, 2018
- Messages
- 8,532
- Likes
- 40,052
I'll take a Ty Simpson from 2A Georgia High School football over a Ty Simpson from 2A Tennessee High School football. If I'm looking at two prospects (one from TN, one from GA) at the same position, same skill set, same speed and athleticism, etc...im taking the prospect from GA.
Anyone who is saying competition doesn't matter doesn't know what they're talking about. That's what the saying, Iron Sharpens Iron, is all about. One of the things that makes Bama so dominant on gameday, is the competition they face in practice all week.
Now, is that saying an INDIVIDUAL who plays in lower classes in TN can't be successful in a place like the SEC? Absolutely not.
I just believe playing HS ball in a place like GA or TX prepares a kid better for big time college ball. The coaches and programs in those places are better, the strength and conditioning programs, the preparation, the size of the games, the stadiums and atmospheres...the COMPETITION.
Again, are there exceptions? Of course!! Trey Smith could have played anywhere, no matter what level of HS ball he played, or where it was played. However, if I had a choice between TN Trey Smith, or a Trey Smith coming out of GA or FL...im taking the Trey Smith from GA or FL. Does that mean I'm choosing right 100 percent of the time? Of course not...but, I bet I hit way more times than I miss.
Edit: I stand by what I've said up top; however, I must admit and own it...I once stated I'd take a 3* Warren Burrell over a 4* Woody Washington (also, factoring into this decision was the thinking Pruitt knew defense and DBs)...I have absolutely no idea what Washington has done at OU; but, if he's dynamite at stirring Gatorade or leading cheers, he's doing more than Burrell.
Anyone who is saying competition doesn't matter doesn't know what they're talking about. That's what the saying, Iron Sharpens Iron, is all about. One of the things that makes Bama so dominant on gameday, is the competition they face in practice all week.
Now, is that saying an INDIVIDUAL who plays in lower classes in TN can't be successful in a place like the SEC? Absolutely not.
I just believe playing HS ball in a place like GA or TX prepares a kid better for big time college ball. The coaches and programs in those places are better, the strength and conditioning programs, the preparation, the size of the games, the stadiums and atmospheres...the COMPETITION.
Again, are there exceptions? Of course!! Trey Smith could have played anywhere, no matter what level of HS ball he played, or where it was played. However, if I had a choice between TN Trey Smith, or a Trey Smith coming out of GA or FL...im taking the Trey Smith from GA or FL. Does that mean I'm choosing right 100 percent of the time? Of course not...but, I bet I hit way more times than I miss.
Edit: I stand by what I've said up top; however, I must admit and own it...I once stated I'd take a 3* Warren Burrell over a 4* Woody Washington (also, factoring into this decision was the thinking Pruitt knew defense and DBs)...I have absolutely no idea what Washington has done at OU; but, if he's dynamite at stirring Gatorade or leading cheers, he's doing more than Burrell.
Last edited:
TheMookieMonster
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- Jul 23, 2015
- Messages
- 29,620
- Likes
- 116,896
cHiZzLeVOL
Who Knows?
- Joined
- Apr 7, 2018
- Messages
- 18,908
- Likes
- 45,090
SSVol
Neeerrrrrddd!
- Joined
- Nov 26, 2012
- Messages
- 8,387
- Likes
- 33,345
Butch Jones was a good coach at the G5 level, at least when he followed Brian Kelly. Urban Meyer was a good coach at the G5 level too. One translated to P5, one didn't. Neither was proven at the P5 level. I'm 99% sure that Saban would win anywhere, because he's proven it at more than one school. Simpson hasn't proven it, but may well succeed. Like most, I'd prefer our guy to have proven it at a higher level of play, but also like most, I value Heup's opinion over my own.
vols 30
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- Oct 8, 2012
- Messages
- 37,546
- Likes
- 42,870
LittleVol
Of course I can help you, Coach Heupel.
- Joined
- Oct 10, 2014
- Messages
- 22,104
- Likes
- 38,939
LittleVol
Of course I can help you, Coach Heupel.
- Joined
- Oct 10, 2014
- Messages
- 22,104
- Likes
- 38,939
No.
No.
It's very simple the error in his thinking.
We're gauging an INDIVIDUAL'S talent based off who he's playing against.
1) Who's he playing with in HS?
2) Is their ANY level of high school football better than the P5 College level?
I never said 2A in TN is the same as 3A in Iowa or 0A in Texas....lol.
That's NOT the point.
EXAMPLE:
Harrison Bailey!!!
"oh he played against the best competition in Georgia "...
.Yes he did, and had HS All-Americans around him.
In other words you can't really rely on level of competition as an argument when you're already superior than everyone else...
cHiZzLeVOL
Who Knows?
- Joined
- Apr 7, 2018
- Messages
- 18,908
- Likes
- 45,090
You can tell me no no no all you want to but a prime example of this is a 1A South Pittsburgh team who played a 2A Team from Georgia and got handled by the same score they did by a 6A Team (Oakland - from Tennessee) but please give me your assessment….No.
No.
It's very simple the error in his thinking.
We're gauging an INDIVIDUAL'S talent based off who he's playing against.
1) Who's he playing with in HS?
2) Is their ANY level of high school football better than the P5 College level?
I never said 2A in TN is the same as 3A in Iowa or 0A in Texas....lol.
That's NOT the point.
EXAMPLE:
Harrison Bailey!!!
"oh he played against the best competition in Georgia "...
Yes he did, and had HS All-Americans around him.
In other words you can't really rely on level of competition as an argument when you're already superior than everyone else...
the same South Pittsburgh team has beat the crap out of everyone else they have played. Except those two teams.
Last edited:
BigOrangeTrain
Morior Invictus
- Joined
- Jan 30, 2013
- Messages
- 78,743
- Likes
- 90,617
DukeDaisySam
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- Oct 22, 2019
- Messages
- 674
- Likes
- 484
cHiZzLeVOL
Who Knows?
- Joined
- Apr 7, 2018
- Messages
- 18,908
- Likes
- 45,090
DukeDaisySam
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- Oct 22, 2019
- Messages
- 674
- Likes
- 484
cHiZzLeVOL
Who Knows?
- Joined
- Apr 7, 2018
- Messages
- 18,908
- Likes
- 45,090
That Dade Co team is a middle tear GA 2A team. They went 7 - 4 in Georgia. The point is Georgia 2A Football is superior to Tennessee 2A Football probably even on par with some 4A and up Teams.
This all to say that Ty Simpson doesn’t have the same experience as a 6A QB from Indiana. Not even on the same par as far as opponents go.
Last edited:
VN Store
