Tony Romo -vs- Eli Manning

[n_huffhines]

OK sure they threw that many, but, how can you honestly say he's good? The Manning love on this board is beyond believable. I can see loving Peyton, but Eli?

He has a SB. He's 60-43 as a starter (.583). And recently he's been pretty dang good:

2008 = 3200, 21, 10
2009 = 4000, 27, 14
2010 = 4000, 31, 25 (with an absurd amount going off WR's hands)

I don't understand how you can say he's not good. Like I said, the ESPN QB rating (which interprets the stats based on circumstances in the game, like INT's off WR's hands) says that he's a top 6 QB.