What was wrong with his college situation? Room? Board? Books? Neyland Stadium?
Do you think he's had great coaching in his time here? If your son were an NFL prospect QB, would you have chosen Tennessee 2010-12 as the best place for him to develop as a player? All I'm saying is this: He didn't develop as a quarterback the way we all hoped he would. But it's not like he was in an ideal situation, either.
The offense last year was about as inept as any I can remember. And true, that's partially on Bray, but he can't make the OL run-block, or our RBs hit holes. It's tough to develop as a QB when those around you -- generally including the coaching staff -- are derping it up every game, and you're essentially down to one offensive weapon (D.Rogers). Not a good way for a QB to progress.
Our defense this year put him in a position where he had to not only be more or less perfect to win games, but he had to be perfect while being hyper-aggressive as a playmaker. On a play where Matt Barkley sees good coverage downfield and throws it away, Bray generally has to try to make a play, because he knows the defense won't let him live to fight another day. Again, not a good way for a QB to progress.
As for reading coverages and going through progressions, none of us really know why he hasn't progressed as much as we'd hoped. Maybe it's because he's lazy or dumb or a punk or any number of other things he's been called on this board. Or maybe it's because the help he got learning to do those things just wasn't very good. Or both. Or neither. The fact is that I don't know, and neither do you.
I do know that 99.99999% of 20-year old men can't learn to dissect SEC defensive schemes on their own without significant coaching help. Maybe he got great coaching and just didn't absorb it. But maybe -- just maybe -- he wasn't all that well coached. Do you think his career at Tennessee would have been different had Cutcliffe been here? I don't know for sure, but I sure think so.
If I'm an NFL GM, I see an extraordinarily talented young man, on a poorly-coached team, who has somewhat underperformed. We all evaluate risk differently, but if my team has a system in place to develop raw QB talent, it's going to be hard for me to overlook someone with as much raw talent as Bray has, especially if I can get him as a value pick.