peaygolf
The "Fly" is open.....Let's Go Peay!!!!
- Joined
- Nov 30, 2017
- Messages
- 25,488
- Likes
- 122,067
Chris Donald!No. That’s Ridiculous!
So based on what you are saying is a 4-5 star in Arkansas, Montana, Nevada, or say Iowa would be a 2-3 star in Tennessee? I saw a lot of HS games when I lived in So Fla. Big time programs like Miami Central, St Thomas Aquinas, Ely, and Cardinal Gibbons. They had 3-4 stars all over the field. Most were rated that high, were so based only by the school they played. A lot were big, fast, and strong, but could not play a lick. Some were phenomenal, and excelled in college and the NFL. Much more than TN, because of the states population, not because they were from Fla. Those schools I mentioned, plus IMG, get kids from all over the south to play for them. Ravenwood is starting to do that....
If you’re dominant in a higher classification in your state, you can play well anywhere.
Absolutely. Always exceptions. Trey Teague and Trey Smith were small school studs.I guess I'll be that guy... Heath Shuler and Carl Pickens played 1A in NC. Shawn Bryson played 2A.
Donald was simply overrated for a number of reasons... one of which was ND's strong interest in him.
I'm not sure why there is such a glut of kids in Florida, GA, CA, OH, LA, and TX, but there is. We can talk about different school sizes or analyze anything we like. That's just history of recruiting. No idea why it is, it just is.Absolutely. Always exceptions. Trey Teague and Trey Smith were small school studs.
My point was if you are a stud at the highest division in your state, you would be a stud in any state.
Yep. Always a crap shoot in recruiting. Obviously, there are some "can't miss kids," but I think just as many 3 stars excel as 4 or 5 stars. The schools that get more "blue chip" players have better odds of five or six will be dominant. Schools that only get one 5 star every 2-3 years, better hope that one kid lives up to the hype.I'm not sure why there is such a glut of kids in Florida, GA, CA, OH, LA, and TX, but there is. We can talk about different school sizes or analyze anything we like. That's just history of recruiting. No idea why it is, it just is.