Actually, almost everything I wrote is factually accurate. The only debatable portion is whether you believe Springer is 10x better than Vescovi as a PG and which position they will play next year. Every criticism of Vescovi’s game is 100% accurate. Vescovi isn’t a natural fit at PG, struggles handling the ball, struggles with passing out of the press, struggles pushing the ball up the floor, struggles getting to the rim, and struggles to create his own shot. And just as in my original post you quoted, I qualified that by saying “right now”, leaving open the possibility that he could improve in all those areas in the future.
That said, I still think Springer shows a greater and more natural ability in all of those areas. Furthermore your comparison of D1 college ball vs HS ball is quite skewed. Springer isn’t playing a typical HS schedule. The competition difference isn’t as great as you are implying. Springer doesn’t play for Karns High School against local KIL competition. He practices and plays for a national program filled with future All-Americans and NBA lottery picks against a national schedule and likewise competition. The IMGs, Montverdes, Huntington Preps, Oak Hill Academies of the world could hang with a lot of lower level college programs. He plays that kind of competition every game, and while it might not be LSU and Kentucky, it is with and against the kind of kids who will play for those schools in next year or two on a nightly basis.