Which Dumbledore was better?

[KingNick865]

Harris was probably truer to the Dumbledore that was in the book.

I don't know if there is a "better" Dumbledore. Gambon's portrayal, as noted, had a bit of edginess to it that mirrored the more somber tone of the later books/movies, but I don't think it was better.

 

[NewToVolCountry]

Reading the books, I thought Harris's protrayal was closer to the books' character.

Harris played it more like the Dumbledore in the book. The wise, all knowing, with a twinkle in his eye Dumbledore.

Having said that, I could not see Harris doing, physically, what Dumbledore had to do in the HP 5 and 6.

I agree. I enjoyed him much more and was really disappointed that there had to be a change.

 

[OrangeEmpire]

The profoundness of the statment lead me to believe that you had to spend at least one or two hours crafting said statement.

work on your sarcasm......not even sophmoric
Posted via VolNation Mobile

 

[NewToVolCountry]

sophomoric

 

[OrangeEmpire]

sophomoric

*with jazz hands* Look at me, I correct grammar on a web board.
Posted via VolNation Mobile

 

[UTVolInSpain]

Harris hands down was the better Dumbledore.