WHY REGGIE MCNEIL?

#26
#26
That Baylor loss must have been embarassing... Yes, Charles, the rest of the wins are understandable.

And VolBeef, you would take Ming Croyle over McNeal? :eek:lol:

Ming Croyle.... Aahhh, too good.
 
#27
#27
ah man I thought the thread would have been over with my last post. I was just trying to explain that they didnt lose to know punks. Lost three games to bcs bowl bound teams (2 of them winning), A&M is no joke coming into this year. 10 win season isn't a stretch for them.
 
#29
#29
Yeah true, but the oklahoma game will be very important as well.
 
#30
#30
Originally posted by milohimself@Aug 8, 2005 4:33 PM
He still is really good, he just doesn't have as good of a team surrounding him. If he played anywhere else than a team with bad pass defense in the Big XII South, his team would win.
[snapback]123985[/snapback]​
Click to expand...

I think he sucks
 
#31
#31
Originally posted by vols2345@Aug 9, 2005 1:19 PM
Brodie Croyle?  Are you serious?  Reggie had 2791 yards with 14 td's.  Along with 718 rushing yards with 8 td's.  you are insane if you rather have Croyle over him.  Proably insane to want Clausen over him.  I can understand Ainge(cause his potential) and leak (he is good),  but not any of the others.  Did you bother to look at the teams they lost to before calling out there record?  they lost to Utah (undefeated),  they lost to Oklahoma (national championship),  they lost to Texas (rose bowl champs) they lost to tennessee (cotton bowl champs), and baylor (which I dont understand but at least it was in overtime).
[snapback]124436[/snapback]​
Click to expand...


Who the hell did they beat that was good? Everyone they played worth a damn beat them. They lost to BAYLOR! Vandy could beat Baylor. They beat a Down K-State and a Down Colorado in OT! Yes I would much rather have a HEALTHY Croyle than Reggie. He is alright at best. Last year 3rd best in Texas. Young, Cumbie then Mcniel. In the Not so Big XII he is ranked even lower. I just think he is getting way to much hype as well as the rest of TAMU.
My prediction for TAMU is 7 maybe 8 wins. Depending on Colorado or Clemson. They will lose to one of them and could very easily lose to K-State on the road.

2005 games

@ Clemson
9/17 SMU
9/24 Texas State
10/01 Baylor
10/08 @ Colorado---------L
10/15 Oklahoma State
10/22 @ Kansas State
10/29 Iowa State
11/05 @ Texas Tech------L
11/12 @ Oklahoma------L
11/25 Texas-------L


 
#32
#32
Originally posted by VolBeef88@Aug 10, 2005 7:20 AM
Who the hell did they beat that was good? Everyone they played worth a damn beat them. They lost to BAYLOR! Vandy could beat Baylor. They beat a Down K-State and a Down Colorado in OT! Yes I would much rather have a HEALTHY Croyle than Reggie. He is alright at best. Last year 3rd best in Texas. Young, Cumbie then Mcniel. In the Not so Big XII he is ranked even lower. I just think he is getting way to much hype as well as the rest of TAMU.
[snapback]125211[/snapback]​
Click to expand...

First of all, "Healthy Croyle" is an oxymoron. And second, Baylor vs. Vanderbilt would be the BCS pillowfight of the decade.
 
#33
#33
Everything you just stated just proves to me that no matter what we show you you have something aginst reggie. So name another team that beat Utah? yeah didnt think so. Name another team that beat Oklahoma during the regular season? what what was that..... didn't think so. Name another team besides oklahoma who could take texas last year? huh huh what was that? yeah thats what I thought man. If you are going to hate on the qb because he has a weak team around him and he willed them to 7 wins last year than you have something wrong with you man. You dont blame the qb for a weak defense. When you only throw 4 int's in a whole season, that is pretty dang impressive.
 
#34
#34
2005 games

@ Clemson
9/17 SMU
9/24 Texas State
10/01 Baylor
10/08 @ Colorado
10/15 Oklahoma State
10/22 @ Kansas State
10/29 Iowa State
11/05 @ Texas Tech------L
11/12 @ Oklahoma------L
11/25 Texas-------L

They will lose thier bowl game too.

McNeil is ok, but not one of the elite.
 
#35
#35
Originally posted by VolBeef88@Aug 10, 2005 9:20 AM
Who the hell did they beat that was good? Everyone they played worth a damn beat them. They lost to BAYLOR! Vandy could beat Baylor. They beat a Down K-State and a Down Colorado in OT! Yes I would much rather have a HEALTHY Croyle than Reggie. He is alright at best. Last year 3rd best in Texas. Young, Cumbie then Mcniel. In the Not so Big XII he is ranked even lower. I just think he is getting way to much hype as well as the rest of TAMU.
My prediction for TAMU is 7 maybe 8 wins. Depending on Colorado or Clemson. They will lose to one of them and could very easily lose to K-State on the road.
Click to expand...



Being ranked behind Young is not exactly an insult, and as for Cumbie, I'm fairly certain my dead grandmother, God rest her soul, could come in off the bench and throw for 400 yards and 3 td's (not to mention 2 interceptions along the line). Leach's system produces huge numbers, but only tepid results. Besides, Mcneal could be the 10th best quarterback in Texas and still potentially be the 10th best quarterback in the nation, sometimes talent just stacks that way ... look at the SEC East. (By the way, I'm not in any way claiming that Texas has that many good quarterbacks, it was hypothetical.)

And somehow I'm guessing the NFL would disagree with you on the whole Croyle and Cumbie vs. Mcneal thing. Just guessing ...
 
#36
#36
Originally posted by vols2345@Aug 11, 2005 12:39 AM
Everything you just stated just proves to me that no matter what we show you you have something aginst reggie.  So name another team that beat Utah?  yeah didnt think so.  Name another team that beat Oklahoma during the regular season?  what what was that..... didn't think so.  Name another team besides oklahoma who could take texas last year?  huh huh what was that?  yeah thats what I thought man.  If you are going to hate on the qb because he has a weak team around him and he willed them to 7 wins last year than you have something wrong with you man.  You dont blame the qb for a weak defense.  When you only throw 4 int's in a whole season,  that is pretty dang impressive.
[snapback]125470[/snapback]​
Click to expand...


I don't know how else to say it but you are just wrong about me having something against Reggie. I am just surprised about the hype. He is a alright qb but not great. You think differently and that is fine. I stand by my comment that who did they beat that was good last year.
 
#38
#38
Originally posted by VolBeef88@Aug 11, 2005 3:46 PM
I don't know how else to say it but you are just wrong about me having something against Reggie. I am just surprised about the hype. He is a alright qb but not great. You think differently and that is fine. I stand by my comment that who did they beat that was good last year.
[snapback]125593[/snapback]​
Click to expand...



Who did Brodie Croyle beat last year that was good?

 
#39
#39
Originally posted by GoVolsDogg@Aug 12, 2005 3:02 PM
Who did Brodie Croyle beat last year that was good?
[snapback]125940[/snapback]​
Click to expand...


OK guys fine. Reggie Will win every game he ever plays in again. He is the greatest qb ever. If we would have had him instead of Peyton we would have won a National Championship. :eek:k:

By the way I am not going to sit on here and defend a bammer. I don't like Alabama at all. I think Brodie is a good qb who has been injured. He didn't beat anyone good due to injury. What was Reggies excuse?
 
#40
#40
Originally posted by VolBeef88@Aug 12, 2005 3:26 PM
OK guys fine. Reggie Will win every game he ever plays in again. He is the greatest qb ever. If we would have had him instead of Peyton we would have won a National Championship.  :eek:k:

By the way I am not going to sit on here and defend a bammer. I don't like Alabama at all. I think Brodie is a good qb who has been injured. He didn't beat anyone good due to injury. What was Reggies excuse?
[snapback]125945[/snapback]​
Click to expand...



Reggies excuse is that he has no defense to help him at all. No RB to help relief the pass rush on him, and a couple decent recivers. I say he has done a hell of a job with what hes got.
 
#41
#41
Originally posted by vols2345@Aug 12, 2005 3:31 PM
Reggies excuse is that he has no defense to help him at all.  No RB to help relief the pass rush on him,  and a couple decent recivers.  I say he has done a hell of a job with what hes got.
[snapback]125947[/snapback]​
Click to expand...


Like I said he is the greatest of all time. :eek:k:
 
#42
#42
Didn't say that he is the greatest of all time, But you have obivously not watched him much this year. I mena you say you do but I don't think you have. I mean you were talking how he throws all these int's when he has only thrown 4 this year. His recivers have jelled this year and will make a big impact. He will proably have a 3,000 pass and a 1,000 yard rushing season. If jay cutler is good on a bad team, then why can't reggie Mcneil?
 
#43
#43
Originally posted by vols2345@Aug 12, 2005 3:38 PM
Didn't say that he is the greatest of all time,  But you have obivously not watched him much this year.  I mena you say you do but I don't think you have. I mean you were talking how he throws all these int's when he has only thrown 4 this year.  His recivers have jelled this year and will make a big impact.  He will proably have a 3,000 pass and a 1,000 yard rushing season.  If jay cutler is good on a bad team,  then why can't reggie Mcneil?
[snapback]125949[/snapback]​
Click to expand...


I have watched Reggie quite a bit. I was wrong on last years ints. I should have said Ints in critical times, thus poor decision making. I have many frineds who attended TAMU and watch them when I get a chance. I still think that he is a alright qb. He is getting way to much hype IMO. CFN had him #3 I believe it was. Way to high IMO.
 
#46
#46
@ Clemson
SMU
Texas State
Baylor
@ Colorado
Oklahoma State
@ Kansas State
Iowa State
@ Texas Tech
@ Oklahoma
Texas

They could make a 10-win season this year, IMO. There's no way they can make it through the regular season with less than 2 losses. Whether it's if they upset Texas or Oklahoma, or drop a regular season game, we will see. But if Texas A&M plays to their full capability, they could make 10-2 this season.
 
#47
#47
Ok here it is
@ Clemson---w
SMU----w
Texas State-----w
Baylor-------w
@ Colorado------w
Oklahoma State------w
@ Kansas State-----w
Iowa State-----L
@ Texas Tech-----w
@ Oklahoma------L ( reggie has done it before)
Texas------w

and a win at there bowl game would make it 10.
 
#48
#48
I will only say this. I think that Reggie is a great QB and I enjoyed all the Aggie fans that came by the board before the Cotton Bowl. They were a great group. I wish them nothing but the best this season. :cool:
 
#50
#50
Originally posted by vols2345@Aug 12, 2005 4:25 PM
Ok here it is
@ Clemson---w
SMU----w
Texas State-----w
Baylor-------w
@ Colorado------w
Oklahoma State------w
@ Kansas State-----w
Iowa State-----L
@ Texas Tech-----w
@ Oklahoma------L ( reggie has done it before)
Texas------w

and a win at there bowl game would make it 10.
[snapback]125964[/snapback]​
Click to expand...

SH!T
 
New posts
You must log in or register to reply here.

VN Store



Back
Top