U gotta decide for yourself if they're really insiders or not.. I have my own opinions on each of them, which I keep to myself.. Jmoore doesn't claim to be an insider, but relays good info a lot.
Good points. Personally I have come to believe that both OCI and Skeeter have connections within or close to the coaching staff and therefore are sources of reliable information. Anyone familiar with recruiting understands that there is a difference between "reliable" and "infallible" -- reliable means that the information is based on what the recruits are telling the staff, but there is no such thing as "infallible" information in recruiting because (1) the recruits themselves are subject to changing their minds, and (2) the recruits occasionally lie to the staff. Most of the time the staff, being adults used to dealing with kids, can recognize when a recruit is lying to them, but occasionally they are fooled by the recruit.
With that in mind, I take the what Skeeter and OCI bring to the board as reliable and I appreciate their input very much but do not look upon it as "gospel" fact -- they can be and occasionally are, incorrect. Nonetheless, they are very good sources of recruiting information.
jmoore is a poster who reads a lot from these threads and also a number of other sites and apparently has a very good memory for what he reads. He brings a lot of information from those other sites and shares it with us, and I am appreciative of his input also because I do not have the time (or patience) to do what he does.
Beyond those three, you have to develop a feel for who has good opinions and who are the BS artists. Good luck to you and Go Vols.
mlsoft