You clearly didn't watch the Opening, and you clearly haven't watched Shy's film. Both are very good prospects, but to say Shy is not in as good of shape based on pictures is just not a fair evaluation. Settle was not quick off the line at the Opening, but Shy looks very agile and quick for a guy his size.
The guy might have been slightly overrated, but the dude can still ball out. He is solid and will make a great addition to this class if there is room. I would wager that we see that rating rise again after his season begins. The guy is good.
He currently has grade issues and doesn't seem to be taking care of his body. He isn't really worth it when we will already have two 5* DT's and another 4* that is really solid. With that said, he was a 5* for a reason and once he gets back in shape I have no doubt that he will be a monster.
I hate to say it but the kid sounds lazy. You have a huge opportunity for yourself and your family and you not only can't get into shape but can't get into shape academically either.