Position-by-position: Battles amongst division leaders
NL East:
Contender: Washington Nationals
Defending Champ: Atlanta Braves
C - Ramos (26) v Gattis (27)
Evan Gattis burst onto the scene as an immense power threat in 2013 before struggling in the second half. Are the struggles a sign of solving El Oso, or will his quick hands make the adjustment? He will need to bounce back from second-half struggles in a more demanding, full-time 2014 role.
Wilson Ramos, notoriously good at the plate and bad behind it throughout his career, will have to show two things in 2014: 1) the ability to stay on the field and 2) the ability to control the running game.
Neither walks much
Ramos strikes out less
Gattis has 30-homer potential
Verdict: Push
1B: LaRoche (34) v Freeman (24)
LaRoche, 10 years older than freeman, is coming off of a near-career-worst 2013 season. One must hold back
vomit while gazing at LaRoche's .198/.254/.318 line against LHPs. Still sharp with the glove, LaRoche has to hope for a bounce-back to stay within the same area code as Freddie Freeman.
Freeman, a fan favorite in the ATL, is coming off of a brilliant +5 win season. He held his own against lefties, absolutely crushed righties, and showed great improvement in the second half. The proud owner of a new contract, Braves fans should be glad Chipper Jones was able to rescue him from snowpocalypse.
Freeman was a top 10 bat in 2013.
Adam LaRoche is, by all accounts, and exceedingly nice guy.
Verdict: Braves, big.
2B: Rendon (23) v Uggla (34)
Rendon batted right around the league average in his 2013 rookie campaign. His walk rate did not match what he posted in his minor league career, but one hopes the former Rice standout brings a more polished approach in 2014. He should be acceptable to above average defensively.
Uggla, despite batting only .179 and looking frustratingly silly at times, had the best BB% amongst qualified second basemen. At times worrisome in the infield, Atlanta fans hope DanDan the Bicep Man has another 25+ homer season in the tank.
Rendon was very good against LHPs, needs to improve against righties.
Rendon, despite star pedigree, has a history of injuries, will need to stay on the field.
Verdict: Nationals, potentially big.
3B: Zimmerman (29) v Johnson (29)
Zimmerman's shoulder issues presented themselves in a big way in 2013, causing repeated throwing issues and eventually seeming to get into his head. Difficult, quick plays were as smooth as usual for the former gold-glover, but time to think, plant, and sling led to issues. He was steady at the plate, leaving Nationals fans yearning for a full, healthy season.
Johnson was a pleasant surprise in Atlanta. Aided by a friendly .394 BABIP, he posted his best offensive season. Given that he is not a speedster, the BABIP likely normalizes, placing his numbers closer to his career, still above-average, marks. Has a knack for butchering it at third base, but the contact bat is welcome in the Braves lineup.
Zimmerman claims that shoulder issues are behind him, though he has been held out of a couple spring training games (could be sickness, could be new baby, could be a problem).
Johnson, a popular regression candidate, should still hit well enough to have a positive impact.
These were actually very similar players in 2013.
Verdict: Nationals
SS: Desmond (28) v Simmons (24)
Desmond has been the best shortstop in baseball over recent years, as the standout athleticism has finally partnered with improved fundamentals. He has 45 home runs and 42 steals since the start of 2012 and has played well above average defense to compliment the offensive output. Swinging early and often, Desmond's offense is streaky and at the whim of moody BABIPs. However, his development into a true 5-tool player is awesome.
Simmons, the newly-crowned defensive champion of all the baseballs, is in the lineup to dazzle at shortstop. Any offensive production will be icing on the cake, and that production may come in 2014, as his .247 BABIP is bound to improve and he has already shown considerable pop. I don't think he will match the 2nd-half numbers, but league-average offensive production from that glove makes for an outstanding player.
It is impressive that young Simba is already challenging a breakout star like Desmond. If Desmond remains on top of this battle in 2014, it may be his last year.
Verdict: Push.
LF: Harper (21) v J. Upton (26)
Harper improved on his great rookie campaign in nearly all offensive categories. Walk rate, AVG, OBP, SLG up... K rate down. wRC+ went from 121 in 2012 to 137 in 2013. Exactly what you want to see from a young superstar. Harper did, however, get slightly worse against LHPs. In a spring training interview, he explained that this was partially due to knee troubles, as it caused backside collapse when he tried to square up LHPs. While this may be the case, he looks noticeably uncomfortable when facing strong lefties... and is likely to see plenty of them. Knee trouble behind him, Harper should get closer to league average against LHPs, continue to terrorize RHPs, and run more.
J. Upton got off to a scorching start in 2013 and, despite some months of struggle, hit nearly 30 home runs and utterly destroyed LHPs to the tune of a 174 wRC+ (2nd only to Giancarlo Stanton amongst OFs). Two causes for concern: 1) he stopped running, for whatever reason and 2) his K rate jumped from 19 to 25%.
Upton and Harper are both good baserunners and good athletes. Both have light-tower-power. Both young stars.
Verdict: Nationals, potentially big.
CF: Span (30) v B. Upton (29)
Denard Span plays a brilliant centerfield, posting one of the best UZR scores in 2013 (behind Carlos Gomez). He also provides league-average offense. A good second half brought his season wRC+ to an acceptable 97. Certainly not a star, Span was abused by LHPs a season ago, but did his job, and even ran more than I expected.
There are not many positives to take away from Upton's 2013 campaign. He didn't die. He didn't kill anyone, as far as we know. He eventually killed the spirits of some fans in Atlanta. Always strikeout-prone, his K% jumped from 27 to 34. Many do expect to see improvements, though. "He can't be that bad again, can he?" I do not think he can, and increased success with the bat will allow his rather attractive stolen base and base-running abilities to play up like in years past. Tools = hope.
Verdict: Nationals, but a push would not shock most.
RF: Werth (34) v Heyward (24)
Werth's bat was undeniably alive in 2013. He posted a 160 wRC+, besting the likes of Votto, Goldschmidt, and McCutchen. He typically looks completely average in the field, but, unsurprisingly, the advanced metrics show that the aging Werth struggles mightily in the outfield. He'll hit, he'll steal some bases, and he'll likely have a couple of stints on the DL. Is what it is.
Jason Heyward is right up near the top of the best defensive RFs in baseball. Good enough to play center, he gets to everything. Ks went down, walks went up from 2012 to 2013. Healthy, he could post another 20-20 campaign. He stole 2 bases and was caught 4 times in 2013, but those numbers could be a product of discomfort from injury.
Werth, despite a great 2013, saw his K% rise. Bad sign for an already older player. I worry the cliff may be coming.
Verdict: Braves, potentially big.
Bench:
McLouth, Hairston, Espinosa, Lobaton, Moore
v
Laird, Doumit, Pena, Constanza, Schafer
Verdict: Nationals
McLouth is one of the best extra OFs in baseball, and actually forms a nice platoon with Hairston when Werth is on the DL.
Espinosa can play the middle infield positions at an elite level and also can't hit a lick.
Moore has the potential to be a good bat against LHPs when LaRoche is sitting on his rear.
Rotations
Strasburg, Gonzalez, Zimmermann, Fister, 5th
v
Minor, Teheran, Santana, Beachy, Wood
Verdict: Nationals.
The Santana addition is an important move. The Fister addition is a better move.
Braves always do well with pitchers and have some great defenders, so it is no surprise that Santana was glad to become a Brave.
Strasburg has superstar potential. Minor and Teheran have the potential to be right there, maybe a tick below.
The gap isn't large, even with Medlen's injury, which calls for a tip of the cap to Atlanta.
Bullpen:
Soriano, Clippard, Storen, Blevins
v
Kimbrel, Carpenter, Avilan, Walden
Verdict: Braves
Craig Kimbrel makes Atlanta's bullpen special. He provides the difference.
Bounce-back from Storen is possible. So is regression from Clip.
Nationals addressed the LHRP need.
Braves will miss EOF and Venters.
Totals:
Push: C, SS (2)
Contender: 2B, 3B, LF, CF, Rotation, Bench (6)
Champion: 1B, RF, Bullpen (3)
Things to consider:
Zimmerman will take LaRoche's at-bats against LHPs, moving Rendon to 3rd and leaving the Nationals in need of Espinosa's bat. This will be a great lineup defensively.
Uggla could be replaced, as the Braves will not endure another season of such struggles.