Yeah, it would be, but you only have so many spots, especially in the fall, and especially for a SG. With Bailey, Vescovi, Powell, Diboundje, and Mashack all potentially returning, can you afford to take 2 SGs? A couple of those guys can play SF in a 3-G lineup, as could JHS.
1. Fulk is out of eligibility.
That is really your only guaranteed spot.
2. Chandler is likely 1-A-D
3. BHH is likely 1-A-D
4. Bailey is a senior, but retains an additional year of eligibility. Does he come back or look for a larger role elsewhere?
5. Maybe JJJ leaves for NBA.
6. Uros or ON may transfer.
Too many talented players is a good problem to have, but it is also the kind of problem that makes taking Tamba a year early a potentially questionable decision.