AM64
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- Feb 11, 2016
- Messages
- 28,556
- Likes
- 42,361
Speaking as a former gifted kid, good on you. The number of us who ended up hitting walls we weren't prepared for in college because we could game our way through the system (public and private) is ridiculous. Even worse is the number of us who ended up with depression because we never could live up to the unrelenting standards our parents and teachers set once they saw that imaginary number.
My kids' school in Ohio (the only thing I miss from there) had a full time gifted counselor that helped bring them down to earth and prepare them for reality. Maybe I would have turned out different if I had one of those. Who knows
Schools should be segregating (by academic ability) and teaching to ability rather than teaching to the middle. Lumping everybody together and teaching rigidly to the middle benefits nobody. India, for example, turns out some very competent people through academic segregation and pushing the limits. As I recall, the joke is that places like our esteemed ivy leagues and MIT, accept the Indian kids who didn't make the cut to the India Institute of Technology (could be wrong about the school name). They don't waste time teaching teaching the brightest what the average kid can master.
Have to agree that if we don't still practice tracking in school that IQ testing doesn't mean much. The problem I saw particularly during HS was that many of us in honors and advanced courses had lower GPAs than a lot of other kids which was demoralizing since so much is based on GPAs. On the other hand, college wasn't really more difficult than we'd already experienced.