Abortion: Should Rowe vs Wade be Overturned?

Should Rowe vs Wade be overturned?

  • Total voters
    0
#4
#4
For the simple reason that Roe v. Wade granted the Federal Government jurisdiction where it should have none.
 
#7
#7
Even if overturned, it will still pass authority to the states. This could actually open the door for either full tightening of restrictions or allowing them in any and all cases. People on both sides might want to be very careful about taking down something that has propped up a 'balance' on the issue since '73. The results of ending this decision actually could cause detriment to their cause by allowing states full authority on the matter.
 
#9
#9
CSpindizzy said:
Even if overturned, it will still pass authority to the states. This could actually open the door for either full tightening of restrictions or allowing them in any and all cases. People on both sides might want to be very careful about taking down something that has propped up a 'balance' on the issue since '73. The results of ending this decision actually could cause detriment to their cause by allowing states full authority on the matter.
Click to expand...

Poop, I agree too.......
 
#11
#11
RvW probably wasn't correctly ruled upon originally. It seems a reach to apply some implied "privacy" right here. However, it has continued to be supported via rulings.

Tough call. Unfortunately as in most tough issues, proponents on both sides refuse to budge from their positions. Meaningful debate is squelched. Medical advances since the 70's call into question the issue of when life begins. Ideally this is an issue for reasoned, thoughtful debate but it won't happen.
 
#12
#12
It doesn't matter. Even if it is repealed, states still have the right to regulate such practices. I am sure some NE states will allow abortion in most if not all cases and the southern states will either ban it or severely regulate it if for nothing more the three exceptions. Ending Roe will not end abortion in this country. All it does is place the issue in the hands of the states and since neighboring states will differ, the SCOTUS will no doubt still have to make decisions on the issue.
 
#13
#13
Right. Ending overturning Roe v. Wade places the legislation back where it should be...with the states!
 
#14
#14
But it will easily go back to SCOTUS when neighboring states start arguing residents crossing lines to allow abortions. SCOTUS will then have to rule on the issue yet again.
 
#16
#16
CSpindizzy said:
Did anyone catch all of the reponses of the candidates last night? Surprises?
Click to expand...
i thought there was a couple that probably didn't say what they really felt, and just fell in with party line. jmo.
 
#17
#17
personally, i'm against abortion. however, i am not a woman, and ultimately, it's not up to me. it's her body and her decision, and she is the one that will have to live with it.
 
#18
#18
Abortions is not a religious or politican question is really a moral question. I can't believe that the american people realize what level we have lowered outselves to. There has been over 48,000,000 abortions since rowe vs wade. We average approx. 1,300,000 abortions a year.
In the last 150 years this country has lost 1,200,000 in wars and that includes both sides losses in the civil war.
Yes we abort more sons and daughters a year than we have lost in wars in 150 years.
Many will yell..."oh but look at the pregnancies of incest or rape etc". Yet that is less than 1/10 of 1 %.
What is the difference between the Holocaust and abortion?. Hitler picked who was to die in the Holocaust. In Abortion we choose which of our sons and daughters will live.
This goes on and on. ...in War we kill each other, in abortion we choose those to not live.
Every single one on this forum has the right to agree with me or not...why? Because we were never aborted!
 
#19
#19
Georgef said:
Abortions is not a religious or politican question is really a moral question. I can't believe that the american people realize what level we have lowered outselves to. There has been over 48,000,000 abortions since rowe vs wade. We average approx. 1,300,000 abortions a year.
In the last 150 years this country has lost 1,200,000 in wars and that includes both sides losses in the civil war.
Yes we abort more sons and daughters a year than we have lost in wars in 150 years.
Many will yell..."oh but look at the pregnancies of incest or rape etc". Yet that is less than 1/10 of 1 %.
What is the difference between the Holocaust and abortion?. Hitler picked who was to die in the Holocaust. In Abortion we choose which of our sons and daughters will live.
This goes on and on. ...in War we kill each other, in abortion we choose those to not live.
Every single one on this forum has the right to agree with me or not...why? Because we were never aborted!
Click to expand...

Do you have a source for this?
 
#21
#21
Monteryvol...thank you for your interest...here is one sourse on the War Numbers....i will post a little late some sourses for the abortion numbers....I see you are one of two that reply..one with his "unaborted" child in his arms...pls check back later. ty
http://members.aol.com/usregistry/allwars.htm
PLs copy and paste
 
#23
#23
Allvol123.... i am sorry if i have upset you.....but life...OR abortion is not a keg of beer is it?....I found maybe two dozens sourses on Google (you can too).....heres one that startled me.
Number of Abortions!
 
#25
#25
Georgef said:
Allvol123.... i am sorry if i have upset you.....but life...OR abortion is not a keg of beer is it?....I found maybe two dozens sourses on Google (you can too).....heres one that startled me.
Number of Abortions!
Click to expand...

Not upset me, I am anti-abortion. You riding in on your horse with cut and pasting posting was what I was referring to.
 
New posts
You must log in or register to reply here.

VN Store



Back
Top