Scotty's Flat Top
I'm hurtin' Linda
- Joined
- Mar 25, 2011
- Messages
- 35,273
- Likes
- 1,803
lol ironically/randomly I had dream you and I were engaged in a slow pitch softball HR derby last night. We each got 3 pitches, and all of mine were like 9 feet over my head and yours right down the middle. I was pissed. Weird dream.
Guys - what am I missing with Jason Heyward? Why does he make the money he makes?
I'm listening to the talking chop podcast and they are talking about how he is was not a bust and I can see where they are saying that. He's still a good player but not what he was hoped to be. Like Scotty Hopson. Hopson was a really nice player but never lived up to his McD's AA hype.
But Heyward is not anything special and they are kinda defending his contract which has to be one of the worst in baseball. The guy is 6'5" 240 plays right field and has been in the league 8 years and he's got 115 homeruns. Career BA is .262.
He's not terrible but he's not even an all star. I mean he's Nick Markakis really.
The guys on the talking chop webcast keep talking about him having a 6wAR but I'm just thinking to myself that just makes me question that stat even more than I already do.
What am I missing?
$200m worth of rf defense and base running?
I have been following the development of modern baseball statistics ever since I ran across the 1984 Bill James Baseball Abstract in a Waldenbooks. At some point -- maybe 10 years ago? -- people abruptly shifted from "We're trying a bunch of different things with defensive statistics, but we've got a long way to go" to "We are absolutely sure that we can calculate defensive value down to the decimal point just like offensive value." It seemed like it happened overnight. And I am still skeptical.
I think theyre pretty dang close to accurate. Strictly from an eye to metric comparison. Metrics tell me Andy Simmons is one of the best and Matt Kemp is one of the worst. Now there are cases where i think it devalues, like Freddie Freeman, but I could be a bias