I go back to the few times that we stopped them on 4th and short. That came down to having the bigger, faster, stronger players. Tennessee's line > Cincinnati's line. Also, that was literally like the only game where Justin and Da'rick were on the same page as far as productivity goes. We had some great breaks go our way. Kind of unfortunate that we didn't see more of that.
In another thread, 1972 Grad made some excellent points which have direct bearing on what you just said. Given the fact that I agree with his conclusions, I will quote him verbatim:
"Then we go into year two of Dooley with his players becoming sophomores, and basically the same coaching staff.
After the second game against Cincinnati, I was convinced that we were on the right track. That turned out to be the ONLY game that Dooley coached with a cohesive, competent staff on both sides of the ball, and all of his weapons healthy. When Hunter went down in the next game against Florida, the team went into shock and never recovered. Then Bray goes down later, and of course Janzen Jackson had already been dismissed, and Herman Lathers was out for the year.
By the second half of the season, Dooley had lost arguably his best 2 defenders (Jackson and Lathers), and his best 2 offensive players (Bray and Hunter). Of course 2 highly ranked running backs (Brown and Oku), who were brought in by Kiffin, decided to leave before that second season started. After running the gauntlet against several top teams while being shorthanded, the team seemed shell shocked, and they gave up at the end of the year.
Then staff defections, for whatever reason, forced a complete rebooting of the team, which proved Dooley's undoing for season 3. Maybe the defections were all Dooley's fault. Maybe the staff saw the handwriting on the wall due to a lack of depth of talent, and decided to move on. Maybe it was a dysfunctional football family with a couple of stars, who were necessary for success, and they couldn't be pushed because they knew the coaches had nobody to replace them with. It may be that the inmates ran the asylum into the ground. Time to move on. We will overcome this period."
For all of the points that Dooley can be legitimately criticized for, he did have an inordinately bad run of luck in terms of losses to key personnel and exceedingly high staff turnover.