Cake vs Pie Debate

[MAD]

Are you team cake or team pie?



Depending on which you chose, which is your favorite kind of cake or pie?

 

[joevol33]

I'd say cake overall, the yellow with milk chocolate icing is my favorite. I mean like the cheap ol Duncan Hines yellow cake, love it. Love a lot of cake stuff, but I've fallen in love with key lime pie.

 

[feathersax]

I'd say cake overall, the yellow with milk chocolate icing is my favorite. I mean like the cheap ol Duncan Hines yellow cake, love it. Love a lot of cake stuff, but I've fallen in love with key lime pie.

Learned to love key lime pie in Miami, but pecan is my favorite
Still make my mother's recipe every Thanksgiving. In fact, I'm about to have a piece now.

 

[joevol33]

Learned to love key lime pie in Miami, but pecan is my favorite
Still make my mother's recipe every Thanksgiving. In fact, I'm about to have a piece now.

Nice. It's hard to beat a momma's recipe.

 

[Tri-CitiesVol]

Cake overall, but pecan pie>anything.

 

[hog88]

Pie

 

[vols 30]

Nothing beats a good red Velvet cake

 

[MAD]

I love Pecan Pie, Cherry Pie and Carrot Cake.
So pie 2-cake 1
Pie wins.

 

[Tin Man]

Pie. Apple’s in the top five.

 

[volmanjr]

Pie
Pumpkin
Pecan
Chocolate
Chess
Chocolate pecan
Coconut cream
Apple
Cherry

Shall I continue?

 

[VolFaninFla]

Are you team cake or team pie?

View attachment 517899

Depending on which you chose, which is your favorite kind of cake or pie?

I love both Pumpkin Pie & Chocolate Cake

 

[JCHateSteve]

This is one of those questions that defines a person...especially a southerner.

Pie! Hands down.

Apple, Peach, and Cushaw are my favorites. That last one is a rare treat in my adult life.

 

[volwindy]

This is one of those questions that defines a person...especially a southerner.

Pie! Hands down.

Apple, Peach, and Cushaw are my favorites. That last one is a rare treat in my adult life.

I'm from the south, and I rarely had pie growing up. My mom also made homemade birthday cakes for all of us. So cake wins easily for me, but it also depends on what flavor.

 

[vols 30]

Might be the only thread where there are no bad posts and every answer is correct

 

[Nerd-Vol]

I say pie. That pains me to say as cake has a lot going for it.

Apple pie and ice cream is king of desserts.

 

[McDad]

 

[MAD]

I'm from the south, and I rarely had pie growing up. My mom also made homemade birthday cakes for all of us. So cake wins easily for me, but it also depends on what flavor.

Kind of the answer my mom gave, she wouldn’t commit to one or the other, she said it depends on what kind it is.

 

[MAD]

This is one of those questions that defines a person...especially a southerner.

Pie! Hands down.

Apple, Peach, and Cushaw are my favorites. That last one is a rare treat in my adult life.

Not a big pumpkin pie fan but this Cushaw pie has me curious.

 

[volz2wallz]

Pecan pie...that's all...

 

[MAD]

Pecan pie...that's all...

Me too, but I’ve had it where it’s been loaded with alcohol, not a fan.

 

[youre no daisy]

both ,peanutbutter pie,pumpkin,pecan,apple .peach, german choc cake

 

[volinbham]

cake in general but I had some chocolate chess pie for TG that was insane.

 

[JCHateSteve]

Not a big pumpkin pie fan but this Cushaw pie has me curious.

Mamaw used to make it. I much prefer it to pumpkin.

 

[JCHateSteve]

I'm from the south, and I rarely had pie growing up. My mom also made homemade birthday cakes for all of us. So cake wins easily for me, but it also depends on what flavor.

Cake was for birthdays but every holiday involved pie growing up. Mom made a mean cake. But mamaw always made pie.

 

[tdawgs]

Sweet tater pie! Nuff said