Not allowing the Chick-fil-A is dumb, and resigning because the school didn't allow the Chick-fil-A is dumb. Dumb is not exclusive to one side or the other. She said that "I am not willing to compromise my faith and Christian values and I will not be viewed as being in any way complicit when an affront is made to those values." Working at a school that didn't allow a Chick-fil-A on campus is compromising her faith?
Politically, I disagree with the Ben & Jerry's guys myself, but I eat their ice cream. Why? Because it's good. I enjoy a good political debate as much as anyone but when you let it influence your decision-making to that level, I don't think that's good.