DirecTV vs. Dish as per my personal experience:
Region-- I live in a rural Kentucky area, very small town that I contest is actually a town. But it has a Wal-Mart store, so I suppose it is. Supposed to be a superstore but it's a lie compared to true superstores I see in Lexington. OK, OK, I'm out in the boondocks.
Dish-- Was my original cable company for about 10 years. I got a low cost package deal that you can't get now that was SWEET. I liked the program and how it fit our viewing needs. I liked the fact that we often had access to programming that wasn't officially part of our package but showed up anyway. This included movies we'd probably normally have waited until discount DVD or Blue-Ray came out. Sports events that were supposed to be blacked out, etc. I never understood this but why look a gift horse in the mouth. But one day the cable box died. They wanted us to pay $115 to replace it plus sign up for new service which would have cost us over twice what we'd been paying. "Bout that time, DirecTV was hunting customers and had a similar package for just 19.95/month for two years. Dish wouldn't match or even near match and kept insisting we pay for a new box plus sign up for an expensive renewal. DirecTV would set us up for just $65 startup fee and the first month paid = about $85 and done. Now you know why we switched.
DirecTV-- It's OK, can't really complain as far as service goes. They're responsive the rare times I do have questions or complaints and pretty fast about it too. To Dish's credit, in the 10 years before the dead cable box, we never had a complaint with them. Shocking, I know but true. DirecTv complaints dealt with billing. Claiming we owed what we had already paid. A call or email got that out of the way each time. But makes me wonder if something sneaky is going on with their billing people.
Dish Likes-- Monthly payments remained pretty low over the years. Increases after the original 2 year contract were low and for long periods stagnant. Sometimes, I wish I hadn't changed cable service because of this.
DirecTV Likes-- Well, it's OK. I am able to see most of my Vols games. Sometimes when I channel surf, I pick up games on channels I never knew I had. Late at night, very late, I see movies or other programming that's not supposed to be available with my package. They vanish as daylight arrives and the channel is greyed out. NO, I don't understand this but again, why look a gift horse in the mouth?
Dish vs. DirecTV-- For me it's mainly this. Despite some claims here, during severe weather both were knocked out in the same frequency of occurrence. It seems, without any empirical evidence, it seems that DirecTV comes back faster and for longer periods.
But I'd call neither one stellar in terms of severe weather performance. The old aerial broadcast systems did better unless the antenna took a direct lightning strike. So neither Dish nor DirecTV impress me in severe weather resistance.
Which do I prefer? Quite frankly, either one that's cheapest based on my experience with both.