Kiffin is not a great head coach.
He is bright, very smart at offensive football, and a good motivator. That makes him an excellent assistant coach.
His leadership style energizes college-age men better than many other coaches. He seems to be about the process with them...focuses on enjoying the ride while doing your best. He is able to teach and develop players without losing sight of the fun of the game.
But he has significant character flaws. Which aren't that critical when he has a boss keeping him in line, but are amplified when he's the guy in charge with no dampener around.
Most importantly for the discussion of Tennessee football, Kiffin has probably reached a plateau in his career. He has been a head coach for most of the past 14 years. He will continue to improve a bit as the years pass, all people do if they're trying, but the big strides have already been made.
What he misses as a head coach is enough to keep him from ever reaching the pinnacle of the sport. He's not a championship coach.
Okay, that's Kiffin. Final note on him as we transition to Pruitt: Lane is, to date, a better head coach than Jeremy.
Pruitt's leadership style is more mechanical, results-oriented. The reward in his cosmos is not having fun, it is achieving tangible results. This will cause him to be less popular with his players than a guy like Kiffin. When players talk about Pruitt, they'll use words like "respect" more often than "like." You can't love a machine.
Not saying Jeremy doesn't have any personality. He does, and it comes out at times. He truly cares for his players; and they can feel that. It's just not a joyous thing, more a down-in-the-dirt, depression-era farmer kind of vibe. We Will Endure is going to be playing in the background of a Pruitt practice, while Girls Just Wanna Have Fun might be Lane's theme song.
That leadership style has not (yet) paid off for Pruitt. Indications are his coaching staff are divided to some extent (we outside the building will never know how much or little). That's a signal that some of his assistant coaches don't share this basic mindset. He will need to find coaches who can thrive in his world; it won't work any other way.
As for the players, I think they'll be fine. They can thrive under just about any style of head coach, if they want to be there, want to win, and are willing to subsume their personal will within the will of the team.
Of huge significance is this: Pruitt is still learning two key things: how to be a head coach, and how to win with players that aren't always more elite than the fellas on the other side of the line of scrimmage. Those are two big learning curves, and he's taking them both on simultanously.
Will he be able to adjust? We don't know. Many here have written him off, saying it is evident he can't do it. I'm not so sure. Time is the only thing that will tell.
Fulmer clearly agrees. He wants to see Pruitt take at least one more step. So no matter what each of us may want, we're all gonna see that.
Given that fact, rather than bitch and moan about our head coach, might as well adopt more of a wait and see attitude.
Finally, Jeremy Pruitt is a human being. He is flawed, just like you and me. He grows and learns, just like you and me. He deserves to be treated with basic human dignity just like you and me. And, as long as he's our head coach, we should all be wishing him the best. We should all WANT him to be a championship caliber coach for the Vols, whether we're convinced he can be at this point, or not.