2. I think a team that manages to be unbeaten most definitely deserves that spot more than Bama. I mean can you imagine how mad we'd be if we were undefeated, but someone else with a loss gets in? What kind of message does that send to the players and fans? Basically "hey congratulations on the perfect season, but we're rewarding the chance at the ultimate victory to someone who has a loss, but it was a good loss!"
1. This is why we need an 8 team playoff. Force the B12 to have a championship game, let the winner of each P5 have an automatic bid and leave 3 spots for potential wild cards like Independents (Notre Dame types) or G5 teams with a strong resume (Memphis or Houston if they beat Memphis, for instance).