I thought Manning was done choking...

[TennesseeFan07]

Yeah, Romo looked very consistent against Buffalo, New England, Philadelphia and Washington. Favre took a team nobody expected would make the playoffs to an NFC Championship appearance (maybe more).

Remind me how successful Favre was last year, at least Romo made the playoffs

 

[tim]

Don't want to bang on Favre.. But, as careers go they are very similar except for the whole addiction to drugs and alcohol thing.

 

[hatvol96]

That's shocking. A Manning sycophant trying to use numbers to diminish John Elway.

 

[VolinArizona]

Remind me how successful Favre was last year, at least Romo made the playoffs

Remind me of how successful Romo was from 1995-2005. See, Romo 06 > Favre 06, and Favre 07 > Romo 07

 

[tim]

going to have to check websters on that one.

 

[**ORANGEBLOOD**]

Other than the fact Favre's not a self promoting clown with an overrated, overbearing jackwad for a father and an overhyped twit for a brother?

Your good at name calling. My guess is its the only thing youve ever been good at your whole life. Anybody with as much bitterness as you have must have been picked on as a kid.

Do you still have to run from bully's at work? I bet so.

 

[DC Vol]

That's shocking. A Manning sycophant trying to use numbers to diminish John Elway.

This will end up having Joe Namath and Ken Stabler brought into this... but only because they're bammers.

 

[TennesseeFan07]

Remind me of how successful Romo was from 1995-2005. See, Romo 06 > Favre 06, and Favre 07 > Romo 07

Dallas>Green Bay

I guess they'll have to defeat the Packers again next week to prove to the non-believers

 

[hatvol96]

Yeah, my life is terrible. Just a litany of unhappiness. Try your dimestore psychoanalysis somewhere else.

 

[JZVOL]

Maybe he can buy himself another Super Bowl ring. He's certainly not going to win another one. While he's at it, maybe he can find a hard up Heisman winner and purchase one of those. Also, maybe he can toss some money at Danny Wuerffel and Steve Spurrier in the hopes they'll sell him a win over Florida.

So it's fair to use Manning's GREAT college career against him but Brady gets a pass? How interesting. His two All Big Ten honorable mentions are things of legend. I bet you were a huge fan of his back then.

 

[DC Vol]

Your good at name calling. My guess is its the only thing youve ever been good at your whole life. Anybody with as much bitterness as you have must have been picked on as a kid.

Do you still have to run from bully's at work? I bet so.

Since I've been reading on his forum (around early 2007) I think you're the 3rd or 4th person to propose Hat that question.

 

[hatvol96]

I don't think Brady went 0 for his career against Ohio State.

 

[VolinArizona]

Dallas>Green Bay

I guess they'll have to defeat the Packers again next week to prove to the non-believers

Which makes the case for Favre that much better. Dallas has far far far more offensive talent than Green Bay. It takes a genius to realize that Owens, Glenn, Witten, Barber > Driver, Jennings, Lee, Grant

Listen, you were 5 years old when Favre started to hit his stride. It's okay to admit you have no ****ing clue.

 

[StunnA N' Orange]

Remind me how successful Favre was last year, at least Romo made the playoffs

Are you really trying to tell us a guy who has never won a playoff game is better than Brett Favre? Trevor, this is really taking your insanity to a whole nother level.

 

[g8terh8ter_eric]

Your good at name calling. My guess is its the only thing youve ever been good at your whole life. Anybody with as much bitterness as you have must have been picked on as a kid.

Do you still have to run from bully's at work? I bet so.

Easy now. Hat's just having fun. Bitterness is something I think that Hat doesn't have. He just likes to get underneath your guys skin and honestly does a great job at it.

 

[**ORANGEBLOOD**]

Yeah, my life is terrible. Just a litany of unhappiness. Try your dimestore psychoanalysis somewhere else.

I bet you still get jacked for your lunch money daily.

 

[TennesseeFan07]

Are you really trying to tell us a guy who has never won a playoff game is better than Brett Favre? Trevor, this is really taking your insanity to a whole nother level.

I'm saying that Romo has done more in the past 2 years than Favre has, can you read?

 

[VolinArizona]

Hat dislikes Peyton Manning less than he dislikes Peyton's obsessed backers.

 

[tvolsfan]

I don't think Brady went 0 for his career against Ohio State.

He also never won his conference outright.

 

[ThisIsWhyImHot]

No, he isn't. Tom Brady, Peyton Manning, Brett Favre, Carson Palmer and Drew Brees are all better at this point.

you did not just bring up drew freaking brees

 

[VolinArizona]

I'm saying that Romo has done more in the past 2 years than Favre has, can you read?

And I'm saying it's a push. Favre's had FAR less to work with.

 

[myrobbins7]

Why all the hate for Brady? The guy is a hell of a QB.

 

[tvolsfan]

I'm saying that Romo has done more in the past 2 years than Favre has, can you read?

And I'm saying that since the list was for this year, Favre having a better this year ends the argument.

 

[SKoreaVol]

I don't think Brady went 0 for his career against Ohio State.

Yeah, because Tennessee had such overwhelming success against Florida before and after Manning that it's clear the team's record against Florida was all his fault.

 

[JZVOL]

I don't think Brady went 0 for his career against Ohio State.

I can't remember how many times the Vols beat 'Bama while Peyton was there...