I understand it does and agree with you. Unfortunatly the UT positions dire straits situation doesn't merit that type of judgement at the moment. If the foundation is solid and a coach takes over then yes...3 yrs is plenty to use the W/L argument. Kind of like your gators and muschump etc. UT doesn't have this luxury no matter how much fans want to think so, and this mindset is what's makes it a better chance we continue down this road with whomever comes in then the reverse. IMHO that's all...
Btw - I believe many of DDs decision were actually well thought out and frankly knowing his teams strengths and weaknesses. The best of coaches make mistakes at times, but some have the ability to have confidence in his team to cover them. Ie...Saban not using his TOs at the end of of the 1st half vs UGA. He was asked about it by the lady reporter when walking to the locker room and he admitted that it was a mistake leaving 2 TOs and his bad but didn't know why he did it.
This may sound like it doesnt compare to some people, but it is actually a perfect comparison:
I spent 12 years as an estimator for a Mechanical Contractor. We did 25mil a year and averaged 15% profit. Not great, but pretty good money.
If I took a set of plans and gave a price on them, I was generally right where I needed to be with my price. I knew my guys, my company, and what we were capable of.
But if I took too close of a look, overthought, looked at the jobsite too closely, got too indepth with my thinking, I would know TOO MUCH about the job, overthink it, and my price would be too high. Too careful can at times be costly.
Sometimes you just have to take a chance, trust that you have guys who can get the job done, and take a swing at it.
I think Dooley was too conservative in crunch time. Just my opinion. (well, me and some folks in my email)