I was shaking my head the entire time as I went down the list. Personally, I like to recommend places based off of what someone wants to eat and which places do that well. As a Memphis native (now residing in Dallas) I consider myself a bit of a BBQ snob but here are my two cents.
General Comments:
- Corky's was the cream of the crop until ~10-12 years ago. I think it got too big and commercialized and has been downhill ever since.
- Rendezvous is a tourist trap.
- Payne's sausage is better than its BBQ sandwich.
- A&R is very inconsistent. When its good, its really good. When its bad, you will think to yourself that you will never eat there again.
- Tops is a fast food style of BBQ, similar to Dickey's in Dallas. Just as you don't go to McDonalds for a good burger, you go to Tops because its fast and convenient. They actually have pretty solid hamburgers.
- Memphis BBQ Company has gotten a lot of attention lately so I went there for the first time when I traveled back to Memphis a couple months ago. The ribs had a great taste but were a little dry. Everything else was absolutely terrible. Maybe I went on a bad day but we left about $30 of barely touched food on the table and got something to eat afterwards.
- Avoid BBQ on Beale. Beale is a street of bars with bar food. You dont eat there for good food, you eat there because you have to if you cant stand up straight.
My Go-To Places:
1. BBQ Shop - I am biased here since my best friend is the owner but this is the place to go if you want great ribs (I recommend dry rub), BBQ spaghetti, and amazing BBQ beans.
2. Cozy Corner - Good all around food from meats to sides to desserts. There is no single amazing thing but everything is solid.
3. Toms Barbeque - For some good spare ribs and bologna. Rib tips are hit or miss.
4. One & Only BBQ - For smoked chicken, wings, and turkey, and ribs. The nachos are also solid.
5. Central BBQ - Personally I think this is the most overrated BBQ place in Memphis. However, they have the best BBQ nachos, which baffles me because their pork alone is below average, but it just comes together very well. It is a great place to go if you want to sit on a patio with a group of family or friends on a nice day and have some BBQ nachos.